Multi-criteria decision making (MCDM) is a research area that entails analyzing various available options in a situation involving social sciences, medicine, engineering, and many other fields. This is due to the fact that it is used to select the best solution from a set of alternatives. The MCDM methods have been applied not only in economics, medicine, transportation, and the military, but also in mechanical processing processes to determine the best machining option. In this study, determining the best dressing mode for external grinding SKD11 tool steel using an MCDM method—the MABAC (multi-attributive border approximation area comparison) method—was introduced. The goal of this research is to find the best dressing mode for achieving the minimal surface roughness (RS), the maximum wheel life (T), and the minimal roundness (R) all at the same time. To perform this work, an experiment was carried out with six input parameters: the fine dressing depth, the fine dressing passes, the coarse dressing depth, the coarse dressing passes, the non-feeding dressing, and the dressing feed rate. In addition, the Taguchi method and an L16 orthogonal array were used to design the experiment. Furthermore, the MEREC (method based on the removal effects of criteria) and entropy methods were used to determine the weight of the criteria. The best dressing mode for external cylindrical grinding has been proposed based on the results. These findings were also confirmed by comparing them to the TOPSIS (technique for order of preference by similarity to ideal solution) and MARCOS (measurement of alternatives and ranking according to compromise solution) methods.