Developing Conflict Management Skills in Hong Kong: An Analysis of some Cross-Cultural Implications

Abstract

This paper reports the results of an empirical study into the orientations towards conflict and preferred conflict management styles of Chinese managers in Hong Kong. The differences in styles between Chinese and Western managers are then traced back to aspects of Chinese culture and traditional values. The difficulties caused by these contrasting styles, both for the transfer of western managerial practices and for the operation of multi-ethnic organisations in Hong Kong, are noted. Similarly, the effects of these cultural values on the preferred Chinese learning styles are also discussed. Finally, the problems of attempting to develop the acquisition of contingent conflict handling skills by Chinese managers in Hong Kong are addressed and two central problems of attitude change and learning style identified.

An investigation of leadership styles and relationship cultures of Chinese and expatriate managers in multinational construction companies in Hong Kong

“…They argued with team members when they strongly disagreed with them. These behaviours contradict the traditional patterns of communication of collectivist Chinese as reported in previous studies (Brew and Cairns, 2004;Gao, 1998;Tang and Kirkbride, 1986;Yum, 1988). It is also interesting to find that some Western expatriate managers place a high emphasis on good relationships.…”

“…Traditional cultural dichotomies (Brew and Cairns, 2004;Gao, 1998;Tang and Kirkbride, 1986;Yum, 1988) predicted that the collectivist Chinese are rather indirect, and rely on 96…”

Empowerment in the Manager-Employee Relationship in Hong Kong: Interdependence and Controversy

“…Chinese people have been found to use approaches that short-circuit or diffuse open conflict and avoid face-to-face confrontation (Bond, Wang, Leung, & Giacalone, 1985;Chiao, 1981). Tang and Kirkbridge ( 1986) found that Hong Kong Chinese favored compromise approaches over conflict, whereas their British counterparts favored direct giveand-take collaboration.…”

Why Should Small Businesses Care About Employee Diversity?: Five Areas of Research that Influence Organizational Results

“…This was attributed to their assertive styles (Tang and Kirkbride, 1986). Individuals that traditionally maintain a lower status, such as females, contribute less in group situations than do high-status individuals (Kimble and Musgrove, 1988).…”