While much is known about non-suicidal self-injury (NSSI), less is known about the impacts of scars resulting from previous self-harm. Since NSSI scars cannot be removed completely, they can affect psychosocial functioning, quality of life, and overall recovery from self-harm, which clinicians must be aware of in practice. A preliminary search of the self-harm scar literature revealed that no existing scoping review particular to the psychosocial, quality of life, and recovery impacts of NSSI scars has been undertaken. This scoping review aimed to address the research gap and assess the extent of empirical literature specific to the topic. The Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for scoping reviews and methodological recommendations of the Joanna Briggs Institute were used as a guide. Four database searches returned 227 potential studies, from which 19 were included and one additional study sourced after screening their references. A total of 20 studies were finally included in the review. Various psychosocial, quality of life, and recovery impacts of NSSI scars were identified, highlighting stigma and shame as prominent among a majority of negative experiences. However, data also indicated some people may experience NSSI scarring more positively. Results support utilising a compassionate, person-centred approach to address the unique needs of individuals who have NSSI scars. Additional implications for practice are discussed. Future research on NSSI scars is warranted, such as exploring intersections of population and scar characteristics that may contribute to diverse experiences and outcomes. Utilising qualitative or mixed methods approaches in future studies may also be beneficial.