Development of a Social Impact Assessment for the Water Environment: A Professional Perspective

Abstract

Climate change and population growth are increasing the frequency of flooding and drought, resulting in conflict over water resources. Social impact assessments (SIA) of the allocation and management of water resources provide a way of reducing and resolving such conflicts. This article first explores the nature of SIA for water environments through an inductive analysis of the cases mentioned in more than 30 papers. Next, it identifies important advantages of SIA over integrated water resources management (IWRM) practices and indicates that while IWRM solves water-related issues to improve social well-being, it cannot entirely grasp the overall social impact of planned interventions. Following this, it analyzes the water environment governance structures in Taiwan, using questionnaire responses from water environment management professionals to discuss challenges of effectively implementing water environment SIA. The questionnaire covers 26 detailed tasks of SIA advocated by Vanclay et al. This research is the first to have evaluated the difficulty of the tasks. The survey results can be used as a reference for the implementation of SIA in other regions. The results show that (1) the water environment SIA is indeed necessary; (2) Taiwan’s water environment professionals need to improve from their current lack of understanding of SIA; (3) it is difficult to implement the water environment SIA; (4) it is necessary for SIA to clarify and integrate the authorities and responsibilities of relevant government departments; (5) the professionals believe the myth of quantification of SIA; and (6) water environment SIA must be integrated with the existing IWRM. Finally, we emphasize the need to integrate SIA and IWRM in a mutually complementary way, and illuminate the need for an integrated SIA framework for water environment management.

Damming Disputes: Conflict Prevention in Water Management

“…Lee et al [54] and Robertson [55] focus on two different policy analysis tools that have the potential to reduce conflict over water management. Lee et al [54] examine the increasingly popular policy instrument of social impact assessments (SIAs).…”

“…Lee et al [54] and Robertson [55] focus on two different policy analysis tools that have the potential to reduce conflict over water management. Lee et al [54] examine the increasingly popular policy instrument of social impact assessments (SIAs). They give an overview of SIAs' relevance to integrated water resource management (IWRM) and then provide evidence of their usefulness from surveys conducted in Taiwan.…”