Development of Product Recyclability Index Utilizing Design for Assembly and Disassembly Principles

Abstract

Designing products for recyclability is driven by environmental and economic goals. Several design for assembly (DFA) rules and parameters can be used to gauge the recyclability index of product designs. These indices can be used for comparative analysis of the recyclability of different products. This assists the designer in making design choices related to the product's end of life. However, many of the existing recyclability indices are only available after design and manufacturing decisions are made. If such design decisions could be made earlier in the design process, when the design space is less bound, recyclability could be considered earlier. A case study is performed to determine if DFA parameters could be utilized to determine product recyclability. The parameters were obtained from existing DFA time estimate tables. The results of the study indicated that the recyclability of the product, as defined by established recyclability metrics, could be predicted through DFA measures. A negative correlation was realized between recyclability and insertion time. Components that required greater time to mate during assembly adversely affected the recyclability of the product. Conversely, handing time was found to have no predictive capability on product recyclability. These findings are used to develop a recyclability index that utilizes the DFA measures, allowing designers and engineers to determine recyclability earlier in the design process.

How ready is the wind energy industry for the circular economy?

“…Thus, sellers and buyers of WT reclaimed materials can be affected either by low selling prices that do not cover decommissioning costs or by low quality materials that make reprocessing technically difficult and costly. Accordingly, incorporating product disassembly principles (Yavad et al 2018) at the design stage of the WTs ("Product and Service Innovation") is crucial to reduce dismantling costs and improve the economic performance of the waste management processes, including recycling.…”

Capacity Development for Plastic Waste Management—A Critical Evaluation of Training Materials

“…Recyclability-Designing products for recyclability is driven by environmental and economic goals. Moreover, recyclability can be designed into products by choosing materials and modularity [29]. Therefore, eco-design plays a crucial role in the manufacturing of products that will be easier to manage in post-treatment (sorting and recycling).…”

Optimization and selection of the multi-objective conceptual design scheme for considering product assembly, manufacturing and cost

“…DfA is a systematic analysis process to aid and guide designers to assemble in an efficient manner [6]. The primary motivation of DfA analysis is to maximize use of the same components and reduce the assembly cost and time [2]. Boothroyd and Dewhurst proposed the Boothroyd-Dewhurst (B&D) method for DFA in 1980, which is one of the most widely applied methods in the industry and business by some companies, such as G.E and IBM Crop.…”

“…As the perspective of assembly of DfX, DfA supports designers to optimize components assembly. At present, the main methods of DfA include Boothroyd and Dewhurst (B&D) method and product function decomposition method [2]. The previous method uses the quantitative indicator to assess assembly complexity.…”