Les plants repiquks se comportel.. mieux que les semis, et . . . De 1957 B 1962 During the period from 1957 to 1962 more than 40 experimental plantations were established at many locations in Ontario t o compare survival and growth of seedlings and transplants of different ageclasses. From 3,000 to 5,000 trees were planted in each area in randomized, replicated designs. The plots were set out by fieldmen in each locality, employing the techniques commonly practised at the time.Details of the experiment and results to the fifthyear ave been reported (Mullin 1968a), and these showed generally better survival and growth of 2-2 stock over the other common class, 3-0. All four species, red pine (Pinus resinosa Ait.), white pine (Pinus strobus L.), white spruce (Picea glauca (Moench) Voss), and black spruce (Picea mariana (Mill) BSP), showed highly significant statistical differences between age-classes. The 2-1 stock was usually intermediate, although often below 3-0 in survival and height at five years.Other studies have shown similar results, Haugberg (1971) with Norway spruce, Finn (1958) with white and red pine, Stoeckeler (1 950, 1963a, 1963b) with these and other species, Cooley (1969) with white spruce, Wang and Horton (1968) pine and white spruce, and Mullin (1968b) with jack pine.The tenth-year measurements of heights of all living trees have been analysed statistically, using an angular transformation for survival percentages, and the approximate method for unequal plot frequencies for the height data (Snedecor 1956, p. 316 and 385). Examples of the analytical procedures are given in the previous report (Mullin 1968a).The results should be considered in the context of the variations within qualities of stock, years of planting, and planting sites. For most plantations the age-classes were produced from the same homogenous seedlots, to reduce differences due to inherent vigor. Variations by years, in terms of climate cannot be correlated with results in any detail, and must be considered in the overview, or overall average situation -beyond specific application or control.Variations between sites, however, affected performance between age-classes. Further reference t o this variation is made later.
Season of plantingThe results, after ten seasons, are summarized in Table 1, by fall and spring planting, for three ageclasses, 3-0, 2-1, and 2-2. Generally, they substantiate the earlier report (Mullin 1968a For personal use only.In red pine it is apparent that fall planting should be avoided unless 2-2 stock is used. Failure may be related to desiccation after fall planting, and the usual poor balance (top-root ratio) of red pine 3-0 stock (Stoeckeler and Jones 1957, Finn 1958, Armson and Carman 1961 .The tenth-year results confirm that planting of white pine should be restricted to spring. Stock measurements at the time of lifting in the nursery indicate that white pine had the greatest relative increase, among these four species, in oven-dry weight between fall and spring lifting; and the greatest relat...