An inflammatory pseudotumor (IPT) is a benign, rare chronic inflammatory process that is destructive to normal histology of the involved organs. While IPT most frequently affects the lung and orbits, it can occur in almost any part of the body. Additionally, histopathological examination is often difficult to interpret, typically showing myofibroblasts and mixed inflammatory and spindle-shaped cells. The histopathological picture may resemble low grade fibrosarcoma with inflammatory cells, making the differentiation between benign and malignant diseases more difficult and potentially requiring specialized histopathological studies. In the present study, a 39-year-old healthy female patient with no history of sexual activity presented to The Specialty Hospital (Amman Jordan) in January 2023 with mild lower abdominal pain. A pelvic ultrasound scan showed a complex right ovarian cyst measuring 6.0x6.5 cm. Tumor markers were normal. The patient underwent laparotomy with an ovarian cystectomy and left ovarian, omental and peritoneal biopsies. The histopathology of the cyst was suggestive of IPT. Other histopathological results were normal. The patient was followed up for 1 year after surgery with no recurrence of the disease.