Syringocystadenoma papilliferum (SCAP) is a rare, benign skin adnexal tumor of apocrine or eccrine differentiation usually occurring in the head and neck region of children. It is a difficult entity to diagnose clinically and even cytological diagnosis remains challenging due to overlapping and masquerading cyto‐morphological features with other benign cutaneous adnexal tumors. Here we present, one such intriguing case of SCAP with its cytological features mimicking those of pilomatricoma. Moreover, the lesion was located at the right lower abdomen, which in itself is a rare site and its presentation was in an adult male which is an unusual age group. However, fine needle aspiration cytology still remains a very useful investigation for cutaneous tumors as it helps in differentiating benign lesions from malignant and metastatic neoplasms and therefore aids in correct treatment and follow‐up of patients.