“…5(d)-(f)) is the nanotube growth which is likely to proceed by a progressive incorporation of carbon at the interface particle-nanotube. This scenario, which implies a root growth mechanism, is supported by the different TEM observations presented in Section 2.1, for the nucleation step at least, and by ab initio calculations [19], whereas in situ diagnostics performed in laser methods [10,12,14,36] and solar furnaces [37] provide information consistent with the first step. We discuss below in more details these different steps with a particular attention to the nucleation one which is the most crucial.…”