Diagrams and Relational Maps: The Use of Graphic Elicitation Techniques with Interviewing for Data Collection, Analysis, and Display

Abstract

Graphic elicitation techniques, which ask research participants to provide visual data representing personal understandings of concepts, experiences, beliefs, or behaviors, can be especially useful in helping participants to express complex or abstract ideas or opinions. The benefits and drawbacks of using graphic elicitation techniques for data collection, data analysis, and data display in qualitative research studies are analyzed using examples from a research study that employed data matrices and relational maps in conjunction with semi-structured interviews. Results from this analysis demonstrate that the use of these combined techniques for data collection facilitates triangulation and helps to establish internal consistency of data, thereby increasing the trustworthiness of the interpretation of that data and lending support to validity and reliability claims. Findings support the notion that graphic elicitation techniques can be highly useful in qualitative research studies at the data collection, the data analysis, and the data reporting stages. For example, this study found that graphic elicitation techniques are especially useful for eliciting data related to emotions and emotional experiences.

Exploring the Daily Lives of People on Methadone Maintenance Treatment: An Occupational Perspective

“…A case study approach allows for the exploration and description of complex phenomena within their contexts using a variety of data sources [28]. This methodology is useful when researchers want to understand contextual conditions that are believed to be relevant to the phenomenon being studied [29] because it "provides a means of exploring the particulars of occupations, at the same time as they are bound together as a whole within the contexts in which people go about their everyday lives" [30] (p. 118).…”

“…This methodology is useful when researchers want to understand contextual conditions that are believed to be relevant to the phenomenon being studied [29] because it "provides a means of exploring the particulars of occupations, at the same time as they are bound together as a whole within the contexts in which people go about their everyday lives" [30] (p. 118). An intrinsic case study methodology, in particular [3], was adopted for this study given its focus upon studying unique subject matter where the results may have limited transferability, but where researchers have a genuine interest in better understanding the case [28]. More specifically, a holistic, single-case design was used to focus on a single group of MMT patients recruited from a single environment (an MMT clinic in Ontario) in order to focus on their unique situation (daily living while on MMT).…”

Artifact Elicitation as a Method of Qualitative Inquiry in Engineering Education

“…Artifacts used can include diagrams, relational maps, photographs, drawings and arts, writings, scrapbooks, maps, television programs, and video diaries. [15][16][17][18][19] Graphic elicitation is common to help visualize and simplify a complex and abstract idea. 20 Both graphic and media based elicitation interviews are often used for children and younger participants.…”

“Sometimes I feel like I’m counting crackers”: The household foodwork of low-income mothers, and how community food initiatives can support them

“…5 No. 1, February 2018 119 (Copeland & Agosto, 2012). Participants' words and pictures were used to elaborate on each other, bringing clarity to the participants' perceptions and strength to the study's trustworthiness.…”