“…It has been demonstrated recently [15,16] that, in addition to the dominant NHC ligand, other ancillary ligands surrounding the Pd metal center also play a crucial role in their catalytic performance. As a result, a variety of NHC-Pd complexes stabilized by different anionic ligands, including cinnamyl, 3, [17] and Cp, 4, [18] OAc, 5, [19] acac, 6 [20] and PPh 3 , 7, [21] were also prepared and their catalytic potential evaluated in direct annulation reactions of o-haloanilines and ketones (Scheme 2). We observed that, of the NHC-Pd complexes that we have examined thus far, all were able to catalyze conversion of acetophenone and o-bromoaniline into the desired 2-phenylindole to a certain extent with decreased catalyst loadings (5 mol%; entries 1-7, Table 1).…”