Differences in central symptoms of anxiety and depression between college students with different academic performance: A network analysis

Abstract

ObjectiveThe prevalence of anxiety and depressive symptoms for Chinese college students are high. Academic pressure is one of the prominent risk factors of psychological well-beings for Chinese college students. The application of network analysis provides researchers a more comprehensive understanding of symptom-symptom interaction in mental disorders. This study aims to find out whether there is a difference in central symptoms between students with different academic performance.MethodA total sample of 1,291 college students was included in our study. Anxiety and depressive symptoms were measured by PHQ-9 and GAD-7. Central symptoms were identified through centrality indices. Network stability was examined using the case-dropping method.ResultsFor the poor academic group, the most central symptom is PHQ-2 (feeling depressed). The most central symptom of the good academic group is GAD-2 (uncontrolled worry). The least central symptom for both groups is PHQ-9 (suicidal thought). Network structure is statistically different between two groups, global strength is not statistically different between two groups.ConclusionThe pertinent symptom is feeling depressed, followed by uncontrolled worry and poor appetite, and for the good academic group, the pertinent symptom is an uncontrolled worry, theoretical explanation and clinical implications is discussed.

Impact of the Japanese Government's ‘General Principles of Suicide Prevention Policy’ on youth suicide from 2007 to 2022

“…17 Furthermore, it has been reported that the internalising symptoms exhibited by students differ depending on their educational performance. 30 Depression was the predominant symptom in students with low educational performance, whereas anxiety (or uncontrolled worry) was the predominant symptom in students with good educational performance. 30 Additionally, students with mental health issues infrequently seek support, which is considered a major barrier to the implementation of suicide prevention programmes.…”

“…30 Depression was the predominant symptom in students with low educational performance, whereas anxiety (or uncontrolled worry) was the predominant symptom in students with good educational performance. 30 Additionally, students with mental health issues infrequently seek support, which is considered a major barrier to the implementation of suicide prevention programmes. 2,31 Therefore, to effectively support students who are suffering from underachievement or worried about their future, their parents, schools and community need to make efforts to observe, detect and implement measures more widely.…”

Association between nomophobia and learning performance among undergraduate students: the mediating role of depression and anxiety

“…According to a metaanalytic paper (Brumariu et al, 2023), anxiety is not a significant impediment to academic achievement, although it is a crucial factor associated with dropout rates and academic self-concept. Similarly, a recent network analysis of college students' crosssectional data (Wang et al, 2023) reports that feeling depressed was the most central symptom for those with a bottom 27% grade point average.…”

Prevalence, correlates, and network analysis of depression and its associated quality of life among ophthalmology nurses during the COVID-19 pandemic

“…Following previous studies ( Mullarkey et al, 2019 ; Peng et al, 2023 ; Wang et al, 2023 ), we performed network analysis in the depression group ( N = 705) to explore the central symptoms and key edges of depression among Chinese OD nurses. Network analyses were conducted using bootnet ( Epskamp et al, 2018a ) and qgraph ( Epskamp et al, 2012 ) packages in R program (version 4.1.2).…”