Different types of social links contrastingly shape reproductive wellbeing in a multi-level society of wild songbirds

Abstract

The social environment has diverse consequences for individuals’ welfare, health, reproductive success, and survival. This environment consists of different kinds of dyadic bonds that exist at different levels; in many social species, smaller social units come together in larger groups, creating multilevel societies. In great tits (Parus major), individuals have four major types of dyadic bonds: pair mates, breeding neighbours, flockmates, and spatial associates, all of which have been previously linked to fitness outcomes. Here, we show that these different types of dyadic bonds are differentially linked with subsequent reproductive success metrics in this wild population and that considering spatial effects provides further insights into these relationships. We provide evidence that more social individuals had a higher number of fledglings, and individuals with more spatial associates had smaller clutch sizes. We also show individuals with stronger bonds with their pair mate had earlier lay dates. Our study highlights the importance of considering different types of dyadic relationships when investigating the relationship between wellbeing and sociality, and the need for future work aimed at experimentally testing these relationships, particularly in spatially structured populations.