Digitalisation without detriment: A research agenda for digital inclusion in the future energy system

Abstract

It is increasingly recognised that the future energy system will be digitalised, and that end-user engagements with this system will be digitally mediated by smart ICT. The digitalisation of the energy system promises significant benefits, but also risks replicating and entrenching persistent inequalities in the ability of households to access adequate energy services. Focusing on a case study of the United Kingdom, this paper explores the links between energy system digitalisation, digital exclusion, and energy poverty, with the wider aim of sketching out a research agenda for understanding the risks, opportunities, and inequalities latent within the transition to a digitalised energy system. Drawing on a review of relevant literatures, the concept of social relations developed by Hargreaves and Middlemiss (2020), and a thematic analysis of a stakeholder workshop, the paper identifies five areas of focus for further research and analysis: 1) the role of financial exclusion and asset affordability in shaping digital inclusion and exclusion, 2) time and temporality, 3) the role of trust in shaping engagements with digital technologies, 4) language, literacy, and communication, and 5) the uneven impacts of digital exclusion on different social groups. The paper concludes with reflections on the practical challenges and implications of pursuing this agenda.

An Empirical Critique of the Low Income Low Energy Efficiency Approach to Measuring Fuel Poverty

“…As well as recording food and energy security scores (via RECS) of the respondents during the winter 2022 period, the survey collected sociodemographic (e.g., age, gender, household income and household characteristics), behavioural (e.g., food and energy consumption habits, and reliance on family, friends or charities) and perceptual characteristics (e.g., life satisfaction and financial anxiety). As discussed in the literature (Dutwin and Buskirk, 2023;Chambers et al, 2022), the deployment of the survey via a mobile app could lead to certain demographics being excluded. Chambers et al (2022) explore the potential digital exclusion of certain individuals or households given the growing digitalisation of the energy market (e.g., smart meters and other internet-dependent services).…”

“…As discussed in the literature (Dutwin and Buskirk, 2023;Chambers et al, 2022), the deployment of the survey via a mobile app could lead to certain demographics being excluded. Chambers et al (2022) explore the potential digital exclusion of certain individuals or households given the growing digitalisation of the energy market (e.g., smart meters and other internet-dependent services). It is possible that households with no internet access, or simply those who are late adopters of digital technologies, were not able to be reached in our survey.…”