To better understand the generation of MHC class I-associated peptides, we used a model antigenic protein whose proteasomemediated degradation is rapidly and reversibly controlled by Shield-1, a cell-permeant drug. When expressed from a stably transfected gene, the efficiency of antigen presentation is ∼2%, that is, one cellsurface MHC class I-peptide complex is generated for every 50 folded source proteins degraded upon Shield-1 withdrawal. By contrast, when the same protein is expressed by vaccinia virus, its antigen presentation efficiency is reduced ∼10-fold to values similar to those reported for other vaccinia virus-encoded model antigens. Virus infection per se does not modify the efficiency of antigen processing. Rather, the efficiency difference between cellular and virus-encoded antigens is based on whether the antigen is synthesized from transgene-vs. virus-encoded mRNA. Thus, class I antigen-processing machinery can distinguish folded proteins based on the precise details of their synthesis to modulate antigen presentation efficiency.