Calcium carbonate minerals, such as aragonite and calcite, are widespread in biomineral skeletons, shells, exoskeletons, and more. With rapidly increasing pCO 2 levels linked to anthropogenic climate change, carbonate minerals face the threat of dissolution, especially in an acidifying ocean. Given the right conditions, Ca−Mg carbonates (especially disordered dolomite and dolomite) are alternative minerals for organisms to utilize, with the added benefit of being harder and more resistant to dissolution. Ca−Mg carbonate also holds greater potential for carbon sequestration due to both Ca and Mg cations being available to bond with the carbonate group (CO 3 2−). However, Mg-bearing carbonates are relatively rare biominerals because the high kinetic energy barrier for the dehydration of the Mg 2+ −water complex severely restricts Mg incorporation in carbonates at Earth surface conditions. This work presents the first overview of the effects of the physiochemical properties of amino acids and chitins on the mineralogy, composition, and morphology of Ca−Mg carbonates in solutions and on solid surfaces. We discovered that acidic, negatively charged, hydrophilic amino acids (aspartic and glutamic) and chitins could induce the precipitation of high-magnesium calcite (HMC) and disordered dolomite in solution and on solid surfaces with these adsorbed biosubstrates via in vitro experiments. Thus, we expect that acidic amino acids and chitins are among the controlling factors in biomineralization used in different combinations to control the mineral phases, compositions, and morphologies of Ca−Mg carbonate biomineral crystals.