Disparities in Reproductive Aging and Midlife Health between Black and White women: The Study of Women’s Health Across the Nation (SWAN)

Abstract

This paper reviews differences in the experience of the menopause transition and midlife health outcomes between Black and White women who participated in the Study of Women’s Health Across the Nation (SWAN), a 25-year, longitudinal, multi-racial/ethnic cohort study. We identify health disparities, i.e., instances in which Black women’s outcomes are less favorable than those of White women, and consider whether structural racism may underlie these disparities. Although SWAN did not explicitly assess structural racism, Black women in SWAN grew up during the Jim Crow era in the United States, during which time racism was legally sanctioned. We consider how we might gain insight into structural racism by examining proxy exposures such as socioeconomic characteristics, reports of everyday discrimination, and a range of life stressors, which likely reflect the longstanding, pervasive and persistent inequities that have roots in systemic racism in the US. Thus, this paper reviews the presence, magnitude, and longitudinal patterns of racial disparities observed in SWAN in six areas of women’s health – menopause symptoms, sleep, mental health, health related quality of life, cardio-metabolic health, and physical function –and elucidates the contextual factors that are likely influencing these disparities. We review the strengths and weaknesses of SWAN’s design and approach to analysis of racial disparities and use this as a springboard to offer recommendations for future cohort studies.

Association of Vaginal Estradiol Tablet With Serum Estrogen Levels in Women Who Are Postmenopausal

“…We included race and ethnicity as a variable because of reported racial and ethnic differences in the experience of menopause. 23 Participants had blood samples obtained at enrollment and after 12 weeks of study intervention. In this analysis, we compared serum measurements of estradiol, estrone, and SHBG concentrations in the estrogen vs placebo treatment groups.…”

A review of African American women's experiences in menopause

“…10 Discrimination was associated with increased measures of pain in both African American and White women, although African American women reported more discrimination. 10…”

“…African American women had a higher prevalence of VMS, and experienced VMS more frequently and for longer durations than their counterparts from other racial/ethnic groups. 10,14 The estimated prevalence of VMS is 80% among African American women compared with 65% among White women. The median duration of VMS is 10.1 years in African American women compared with a median of 6.5 years in White women.…”

Normalising menopause

“…A 2021 international scoping review found that social factors including systemic discrimination, racism, and sexism together with personal factors such as socioeconomic status and beliefs about menopause shaped the experience of menopause in migrant women 11. In the US, menopause is earlier, and vasomotor symptoms more common and long lasting, in African American than in white American women 12. The reasons for these disparities are not known but structural racism, inequalities, and ongoing life stressors may contribute.…”