Disqualified Bodies: A Sociolegal Analysis of the Organ Trade in Cairo, Egypt

Abstract

Legislative and policy interventions in response to the organ trade have centered on the introduction of criminal sanctions in an effort to deter organ sales and/or “trafficking.” Yet, such measures fail to take account of the social and political processes that facilitate the exploitation of individuals in organ markets in different contexts. Informed by empirical data, gathered via a series of in‐depth interviews with Sudanese migrants who have sold a kidney, this paper examines the link between increased urbanization, migration patterns, informalization, and the emergence of organ markets in the Egyptian‐Sudanese context. The findings illustrate how processes of legal marginalization and social exclusion leave people vulnerable to exploitation in organ markets. The prevailing law enforcement response does not capture or respond to the empirical reality. Accordingly, this paper shifts the emphasis away from criminalization toward an analysis of the legal barriers and policy decisions that shape the poor bargaining position of organ sellers. In doing so, it opens up discussion of the organ trade onto wider critiques that disrupt boundaries between formality and informality in labor markets and trouble dominant modes of criminalization.

The state of the organ trade: Narratives of corruption in Egypt and Bangladesh

“…Our job is to provide medical care for patients, not to prove family ties of them." While the role of transplant professionals may be limited to performing the surgery, many are willfully blind to the exploitation of impoverished donors: more transplants mean more profits (see also Mendoza 2010;Columb 2017). In some cases, transplant professionals actively collaborate with brokers to recruit donor-sellers and patient-buyers.…”

Criminele netwerken achter orgaanhandel: een sociale netwerkanalyse van de Medicus-zaak

“…Potentiële donoren kunnen een recruiter ook zelf benaderen (UNODC, 2015). Een recruiter is soms zelf een voormalig donor en slachtoffer van orgaanhandel (Budiani-Saberi e.a., 2014;Columb, 2017a). Daarnaast worden brokers onderscheiden.…”

Child trafficking crime and means of fighting it: Egypt as a case study

“…Poverty and unemployment are among the main causes of human trafficking in Egypt, and the individual may resort to it to escape poverty and unemployment. Moreover, economic conditions have led to an expansion of the “informal economy” that may deprive workers of their ability to bargain for their rights, recognized official labor standards and rights, such as minimum wages, social solidarity rights and safe working conditions, with the possibility of violations in informal work activities that act as a hidden form of paid employment (Columb, 2017). Economic conditions were also a major factor in the rise of the phenomenon of illegal immigration, especially in view of the high cost of legal migration and its strict policies.…”