We sought to study the binding constraints placed on the nine-zinc-finger protein transcription factor IIIA (TFIIIA) by a histone octamer. To this end, five overlapping fragments of the Xenopus laevis oocyte and somatic 5S rRNA genes were reconstituted into nucleosomes, and it was subsequently shown that nucleosome translational positioning is a major determinant of the binding of TFIIIA to the 5S rRNA genes. Furthermore, it was found that histone acetylation cannot override the TFIIIA binding constraints imposed by unfavorable translational positions.Xenopus laevis produces two major types of 5S rRNA: the somatic type is synthesized in most cell types, whereas the oocyte type is synthesized during early oogenesis, during embryogenesis, and in certain tissue culture cell lines (14,47). Each 5S rRNA type is transcribed from a distinct multigene family, and considerable research has focused on understanding the differential expression of these genes. One hypothesis suggests that the transcription complexes which form on the oocyte genes are relatively unstable compared to those of the somatic counterparts. As a result of this, the oocyte genes are transcribed only when transcription factor IIIA (TFIIIA) levels are relatively high, as is the case during oogenesis. In somatic cells, in which TFIIIA levels are much lower, the transcription complexes dissociate from the oocyte gene, allowing the subsequent assembly of repressive nucleosome structures which preclude further factor binding (47). Conflicting with this hypothesis are results which show that, at least in vitro, the RNA polymerase III transcription complexes, once formed, have similar stabilities on both the oocyte and somatic genes (35). Thus, at this time, the reasons for the differential transcription of these two gene families in X. laevis are not fully understood.The results of 5S rRNA gene transcription studies, performed with both native and reconstituted chromatin as templates, have been conflicting. In one such study it was demonstrated that chromatin isolated from a Xenopus kidney cell line can serve as a template for transcription of the oocyte gene after the removal of histone H1 (34). In addition, it has been shown that incorporation of a somatic histone H1 variant into chromatin during embryogenesis results in specific repression of TFIIIA-activated oocyte 5S rRNA transcription (8). Furthermore, histone H1 has been shown to specifically repress transcription of oocyte genes in reconstituted chromatin while leaving the corresponding somatic genes unaffected (40). These results suggest that it is the presence of histone H1 which is responsible for the repression of oocyte transcription. This is not surprising considering that histone H1 is thought of as a repressor of transcription, although the exact mechanism of this repression is not known. In contrast to the abovementioned work, studies with chromatin reconstituted in the absence of linker histones have shown that the presence of nucleosome core particles alone is sufficient to repress oocyt...