Disruption of the HIF-1 pathway in individuals with Ollier disease and Maffucci syndrome

Abstract

Ollier disease (OD) and Maffucci Syndrome (MS) are rare disorders characterized by multiple enchondromas, commonly causing bone deformities, limb length discrepancies, and pathological fractures. MS is distinguished from OD by the development of vascular anomalies. Both disorders are cancer predisposition syndromes with malignancies developing in ~50% of the individuals with OD or MS. Somatic gain-of-function variants in IDH1 and IDH2 have been described in the enchondromas, vascular anomalies and chondrosarcomas of approximately 80% of the individuals with OD and MS. To date, however, no investigation of germline causative variants for these diseases has been comprehensively performed. To search for germline causative variants, we performed whole exome sequencing or whole genome sequencing of blood or saliva DNA in 94 unrelated probands (68 trios). We found that 7 had rare germline missense variants in HIF1A, 6 had rare germline missense variants in VHL, and 3 had IDH1 variants including 2 with mosaic IDH1-p.Arg132His variant. A burden analysis using 94 probands assigned as cases and 2,054 unrelated individuals presenting no OD- or MS-related features as controls, found that variants in HIF1A, VHL, and IDH1 were all significantly enriched in cases compared to controls. To further investigate the role of HIF-1 pathway in the pathogenesis of OD and MS, we performed RNA sequencing of fibroblasts from 4 probands with OD or MS at normoxia and at hypoxia. When cultured in hypoxic conditions, both proband and control cells showed altered expression of a subset of HIF-1 regulated genes. However, the set of differentially expressed genes in proband fibroblasts included a significantly reduced number of HIF-1 regulated genes compared to controls. Our findings suggest that germline or early post-zygotic variants identified in HIF1A, VHL, and IDH1 in probands with OD and MS underlie the development of the phenotypic abnormalities in a subset of individuals with OD and MS, but extensive functional studies are needed to further confirm it.

Hypoxic Conditions Modulate Chondrogenesis through the Circadian Clock: The Role of Hypoxia-Inducible Factor-1α

“…As demonstrated above, HIF-1α plays an important role in chondrogenesis and in the physiological lifecycle of articular cartilage. However, HIF-1α-related malfunctions, from excessive induction to abnormal downstream signaling, are widely reported in cartilage-related pathologies [ 99 , 100 ]. Here, we focus only on the two most-documented fields: OA and chondrosarcoma.…”

“…In all skeletal tumors, the common cellular mechanisms affected by HIF-1α are cell proliferation, tissue vascularization and metastasis formation [ 117 , 118 , 119 ]. Although cartilage-related malignancies are referenced in a rich literature regarding hypoxia, the role of HIF-1α is also implicated in enchondromas [ 100 ]. Isocitrate dehydrogenase 1 mutations were reported to induce HIF-1α and consequently influence angiogenic properties and tumorigenicity in the JJ012 human chondrosarcoma cell line [ 120 ].…”