Here we use the fluorescence from a genetically encoded unnatural amino acid, L-(7-hydroxycoumarin-4-yl)ethylglycine (HCE-Gly) replacing an amino acid in the regulatory site of Escherichia coli aspartate transcarbamoylase (ATCase) to decipher the molecular details of regulation of this allosteric enzyme. The fluorescence of HCE-Gly is exquisitely sensitive to the binding of all four nucleotide effectors. Although ATP and CTP are primarily responsible for influencing enzyme activity, the results of our fluorescent binding studies indicate that UTP and GTP bind with similar affinities, suggesting a dissociation between nucleotide binding and control of enzyme activity. Furthermore, while CTP is the strongest regulator of enzyme activity, it binds selectively to only a fraction of regulatory sites, allowing UTP to effectively fill the residual ones. Our results suggest that CTP and UTP are not competing for the same binding sites, but instead reveal an asymmetry between the two allosteric sites on the regulatory subunit of the enzyme. Correlation of binding and activity measurements explain how ATCase uses asymmetric allosteric sites to achieve regulatory sensitivity over a broad range of heterotropic effector concentrations.Enzymes responsible for catalyzing the committed step of critical metabolic pathways, such as aspartate transcarbamoylse (ATCase) in pyrimidine nucleotide biosynthesis, are often regulated by allosteric mechanisms. Allosteric regulation provides a rapid means for turning a pathway on or off dictated by the specific needs of the cell at any point in time. Escherichia coli ATCase has been investigated extensively and has come to serve as a paradigm for allosteric enzymes (1). ATCase is regulated by both homotropic and heterotropic effectors involving the cooperative binding of the second substrate, aspartate, at the active site and nucleotide binding at the allosteric site. The active and allosteric sites are located ~60Å apart on different polypeptide chains of the holoenzyme, a dodecamer composed of six catalytic chains (c) and six regulatory chains (r) (Figure 1, panel a), which can be dissociated into two catalytically active trimers (c 3 ) and three nucleotide-binding regulatory dimers (r 2 ) (2).Kinetic studies revealed activation by ATP, inhibition by CTP, and the synergistic inhibition of UTP in the presence of CTP (3). However, the elucidation of the allosteric mechanism of regulation in ATCase has been exceedingly difficult with many conflicting results. The interactions of the regulatory nucleotides with the enzyme have been investigated using a variety of methods including equilibrium dialysis (4-8), continuous-flow dialysis (9), nuclear magnetic resonance (10,11), site-specific mutagenesis (8,10-13), and X-ray crystallography (14,15). Some of these experiments indicate two classes of nucleotide binding sites with differing affinities suggesting either a non-equivalence of binding sites or negative cooperativity (7). However, these methods lack the sensitivity to accurately * ...