bFor almost 2 decades, results from Chlamydia pathogenesis investigations have been conceptualized using a cytokine polarization narrative. Recent viral immunity studies identifying protective tissue-resident memory T cells (Trm) suggest an alternative paradigm based on localized immune networks. As Chlamydia vaccines enter the preclinical pipeline and, in the case of an attenuated trachoma vaccine, are given to human subjects, it may be useful to ask whether cytokine polarization is the appropriate framework for understanding and evaluating vaccine efficacy. In this review, we revisit C. trachomatis pathogenesis data from mice and humans using a Trm narrative and note a comfortable concordance with the Chlamydia pathogenesis literature.
Chlamydia trachomatis infections of ocular and genital tract mucosal epithelia elicit host responses that include formation of submucosal lymphoid aggregates that persist at the site of infection after infectious bacteria are no longer present. In trachoma, these aggregates, called follicles, are easily visible without magnification on routine physical examination and are used to make the clinical diagnosis. Lymphoid aggregates have also been documented in uterine and cervical samples of women with C. trachomatis genital tract infections and are seen in the C. muridarum mouse model of genital tract infections (detailed below).Investigators have speculated about a role for local lymphoid aggregates in protective immunity to Chlamydia. Most presciently, Morrison and Morrison concluded that the "persistence of CD4ϩ -T-cell clusters long after infection had resolved (day 70) may provide for a readily mobilizable T-cell response by which previously infected animals can quickly respond to and control a secondary infectious challenge" (1). Strikingly, this concept is not featured in working models of Chlamydia immunopathogenesis. Instead, CD4 T cell cytokine polarization (Th1, Th2, Th17, . . .) has served as theoretical scaffolding for describing immunoprotection and immunopathology associated with infection. It is unclear whether cytokine polarization is the appropriate framework for understanding Chlamydia pathogenesis. Recent work in viral pathogenesis has identified semiautonomous tissue-localized lymphoid structures containing memory T cells as being critical for protective antiviral immunity (2, 3). The available data suggest that the tissue-resident memory T cells (Trm) in lymphoid aggregates formed in response to C. trachomatis infection play a central role in protective and pathological immune responses in the eye and genital tract.
TISSUE-RESIDENT MEMORY T CELLSTrm were originally described for CD8 T cells in the setting of recurrent herpes simplex virus (HSV) reactivations. HSV infects peripheral sensory nerves at the site of infection and travels in a retrograde manner up nerve axons to set up a latent infection in the associated sensory ganglion. When HSV reactivates due to UV exposure or stress, it travels back down the nerve axon and infects the stromal cells adjacent to...