Dedicated to Professor Gernot Boche on the occasion of his 70th birthdayThe thermal ion-molecule reactions NiX þ þ CH 4 ! Ni(CH 3 ) þ þ HX (X ¼ H, CH 3 , OH, F) have been studied by mass spectrometric methods, and the experimental data are complemented by density functional theory (DFT)-based computations. With regard to mechanistic aspects, a rather coherent picture emerges such that, for none of the systems studied, oxidative addition/reductive elimination pathways are involved. Rather, the energetically most favored variant corresponds to a s-complexassisted metathesis (s-CAM). For X ¼ H and CH 3 , the ligand exchange follows a two-state reactivity (TSR) scenario such that, in the course of the thermal reaction, a twofold spin inversion, i.e., triplet ! singlet ! triplet, is involved. This TSR feature bypasses the energetically high-lying transition state of the adiabatic ground-state triplet surface. In contrast, for X ¼ F, the exothermic ligand exchange proceeds adiabatically on the triplet ground state, and some arguments are proposed to account for the different behavior of NiX þ /Ni(CH 3 ) þ (X ¼ H, CH 3 ) vs. NiF þ . While the couple Ni(OH) þ /CH 4 does not undergo a thermal ligand switch, the DFT computations suggest a potential-energy surface that is mechanistically comparable to the NiF þ /CH 4 system. Obviously, the ligands X act as a mechanistic distributor to switch between single vs. two-state reactivity patterns.