The chaperonin proteins GroEL and GroES are cellular nanomachines driven by the hydrolysis of ATP that facilitate the folding of structurally diverse substrate proteins. In response to ligand binding, the subunits of a ring cycle in a concerted manner through a series of allosteric states (T, R, and R″), enabling work to be performed on the substrate protein. Removing two salt bridges that ordinarily break during the allosteric transitions of the WT permitted the structure of GroEL-ADP in the R state to be solved to 2.7 Å resolution. Whereas the equatorial domain displays almost perfect sevenfold symmetry, the apical domains, to which substrate proteins bind, and to a lesser extent, the intermediate domains display a remarkable asymmetry. Freed of intersubunit contacts, the apical domain of each subunit adopts a different conformation, suggesting a flexibility that permits interaction with diverse substrate proteins. This result contrasts with a previous cryo-EM study of a related allosteric ATP-bound state at lower resolution. After artificially imposing sevenfold symmetry it was concluded that a GroEL ring in the R-ATP state existed in six homogeneous but slightly different states. By imposing sevenfold symmetry on each of the subunits of the crystal structure of GroEL-ADP, we showed that the synthetic rings of (X-ray) GroEL-ADP and (cryo-EM) GroEL-ATP are structurally closely related. A deterministic model, the click stop mechanism, that implied temporal transitions between these states was proposed. Here, however, these conformational states are shown to exist as a structurally heterogeneous ensemble within a single ring.protein machine | allostery | chaperonin T o assist protein folding, the GroEL/GroES chaperonin machine cycles through a series of conformational states in response to ligand binding (1-3). Two states, taut (T) and relaxed (R), are populated in the absence of GroES. Another two states, R′ and R″, that exist before and after ATP hydrolysis, respectively, are populated on GroES binding to the R state (1-3) (Fig. 1A). Crystal structures of T [Protein Data Bank (PDB) ID code 1OEL] (4) (PDB ID code 1XCK) (5), R′ (PDB ID code 1SVT) (6), and R″ (PDB ID code 1AON) (7) states are available.As described by the theory of nested cooperativity, the conformational transitions within each heptameric ring are positively cooperative, whereas the transitions between the rings are negatively cooperative (8, 9). Multiple salt bridges, some within a subunit and others between subunits, stabilize these various conformational states. In such a dynamic system, these salt bridges must continually be broken and reformed at different points during the chaperonin cycle. Two interdomain salt bridges, an intrasubunit one (D83-K327) and an intersubunit one (R197-E386), stabilize the T state and are ordinarily broken during the T to R transition that follows the binding of ATP to the WT (Fig. 1B). Individually, the R197A mutation destabilizes the T state (10, 11), whereas replacing the D83-K327 salt bridge with a disulfid...