During indigo dyeing fermentation, indigo reduction for the solubilization of indigo particles occurs through the action of microbiota under anaerobic alkaline conditions. The original microbiota in the raw material (sukumo: composted indigo plant) should be appropriately converged toward the extracellular electron transfer (EET)-occurring microbiota by adjusting environmental factors for indigo reduction. The convergence mechanisms of microbiota, microbial physiological basis for indigo reduction, and microbiota led by different velocities in the decrease in redox potential (ORP) at different fermentation scales were analyzed. A rapid ORP decrease was realized in the big batch, excluding Actinomycetota effectively and dominating Alkalibacterium, which largely contributed to the effective indigo reduction. Functional analyses of the microbiota related to strong indigo reduction on approximately day 30 indicated that the carbohydrate metabolism, prokaryotic defense system, and gene regulatory functions are important. Because the major constituent in the big batch was Alkalibacterium pelagium, we attempted to identify genes related to EET in its genome. Each set of genes for flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD) transportation to modify the flavin mononucleotide (FMN)-associated family, electron transfer from NADH to the FMN-associated family, and demethylmenaquinone (DMK) synthesis were identified in the genome sequence. The correlation between indigo intensity reduction and metabolic functions suggests that V/A-type H+/Na+-transporting ATPase and NAD(P)H-producing enzymes drive membrane transportations and energization in the EET system, respectively.