Melanocytic nevi are one of the most common diagnoses in the daily practice of any dermatopathologist. Although in the vast majority of cases the final diagnosis is not difficult, there are certain rare and unusual morphologic variations that can elicit some diagnostic problems. Although some of these variations can be considered as mere morphologic oddities, others might lead to a differential diagnosis with melanoma, or with other tumors, including epithelial or neural tumors. In the current report, we review many of these morphologic variations and discuss the main differential diagnosis, when appropriate.