Cold marinades are produced mainly from the Clupeidae fish, because meat of other fish species does not reach a desired level of ripeness in the acid-salt environment of fresh brine. Hence, this work presents an innovative idea of reusing brine including cathepsins and peptides for marinating cod, salmon, trout, and carp. The extent of marinades ripening improvement depended on fish resistance to the marinating process. The reused brine proved best in improving the ripening of fatty fish (salmon and trout), which were qualified to the first class of resistance to marinating. In the case of cod, the reuse of brine did not elicit a satisfactory improvement in meat ripening. Therefore cod was qualified to the second class of resistance. The reuse of brine resulted in decreased values of lipid oxidation indices (except for cod) and meat hardness, and in increased scores for overall sensory evaluation and total volatile bases nitrogen value.