Divergent and Similar Experiences of ‘Gating’ in South Africa: Johannesburg, Durban and Cape Town

Abstract

The last 20 years has witnessed an explosion not only in the growth of private residential territories throughout the world, but also in the literature addressing them. The majority of research is centred on experiences in the United States and Latin America (although studies elsewhere are increasing) and suffers from a tendency to homogenise the processes and consequences of gating as synonymous whether experienced in Los Angeles, New York, Mexico City or São Paulo. Whilst axiomatic to state the unlikelihood of identical trends in such differing contexts, the absence of such a statement in the literature is significant. This paper addresses the social and spatial phenomenon of residential gated communities in three of South Africa's major cities: Johannesburg, Durban and Cape Town. Detailed background and discussion regarding the development and experience of 'gating' in each city is analysed, emphasising the uniqueness of each city's gating experience. These indications, that gating is not a universal experience despite some common themes, serve to counter the homogenous discourse in both popular and academic parlance throughout the world and within South Africa. In addition, particular concerns related to the growth of residential forms based on exclusion and privatisation within the South African context, are considered. In essence, we conclude that while 'gating' may be an individually rational decision in the context of South Africa's growing crime, its collective consequences produce a divided city, at odds with post-apartheid ideals of unity and equality.Urban Forum (

Transitory Mobility, Cultural Heterogeneity, and Victimization Risk Among Young Men of Color: Insights From an Ethnographic Study in Cape Town, South Africa

“…Individuals classified as “Coloured” under apartheid were of mixed heritage, including descendants of Dutch settlers, Malay or West African slaves, and/or indigenous people, with sufficiently light skin, smoothly textured hair, and Coloured social networks to meet this designation (Posel, ). Cape Town's large Coloured population is unusual because Blacks are 79 percent of the South African population and the majority of residents in its other large cities (Lemanski, Landman, and Durington, ). The Group Areas Act spatially segregated South Africa's officially classified racial groups, with Cape Town designated a Coloured Labor Preference Area.…”

“…To the south and north of downtown Cape Town are tree‐lined and often fortified “formerly” White suburbs, in which four fifths of new residential housing is in gated communities (Lemanski, Landman, and Durington, : 147). Moreover, property values in “formerly” White suburbs “are up to one hundred times greater than in formal townships,” and the gap has widened post‐apartheid (Besteman, : 54).…”

Rescaling White Space in Post‐apartheid Johannesburg

“…In many northern suburbs, residents have torn up sidewalks and replaced them with ivy in order to decrease pedestrian traffic. RAs have also closed roads, erected gates, and hired private security companies to regulate access to their neighborhoods (Dirsuweit ; Dirsuweit and Wafer ; Lemanski, Landman and Durington ).…”

More than twenty years after the repeal of the Group Areas Act: housing, spatial planning and urban development in post-apartheid South Africa

“…In that month, the South African Human Rights commission declared the erection of boom gates and other measures of enclosure a violation of the human rights (Lemanski et al 2008, p. 135). This judgment Housing, spatial planning and urban development in post-apartheid South Africa 583 encouraged a lot of city councils across the country to implement stricter guidelines with respect to road closures and fenced-off neighborhoods (Lemanski et al 2008). In this special issue, two articles concentrate on the private sector.…”