Notch signalling is a major signalling pathway coordinating cellular processes between neighbouring animal cells. In Drosophila, two ubiquitin ligases, Neuralized (Neur) and Mindbomb1 (Mib1), regulate Notch ligand activation and are essential for development. However, the mammalian orthologs of Neur, Neuralized-like (NEURL) 1 and 2, do not appear to be crucial for development, as double knock-out mice show no developmental defects. Thus, it is unclear if and how NEURL proteins regulate the four mammalian Notch ligands. To address these questions, we examined NEURL proteins ability to activate Notch ligands in humanized Drosophila and mammalian cell culture. We found that, unlike MIB1, NEURL proteins activate Notch only with a subset of mammalian ligands, which contain a Neuralized binding motif. This motif has the consensus sequence NxxN, present only in Notch ligands DLL1 and JAG1, but not in DLL4 and JAG2. Overall, we show that NEURL proteins activate specific Notch-ligands, suggesting a differential regulatory mechanism of Notch activation in mammals, which can potentially explain the limited role of NEURL proteins in mammalian development and homeostasis.