Diversity without Pluralism: Religious Landscape in Mainland China

Abstract

Abstract:The paper explores religious diversity and pluralism in the religioscape of mainland China with three examples. While religious diversity is de facto practice, "religious pluralism" is not socially recognised, culturally legitimised, or discursively institutionalised. On the one hand, state co-option of religious groups is achieved through particular definition of "religion" without the conceptualisation of pluralism, leaving undefined religious activities to cultural policy or national security measures. On the other hand, practices that might be identified as religious elsewhere does not usually self-identified as such, not to say seek for the right of religious freedom. To explain the absence of articulated/institutionalised "religious pluralism" in China, the paper provides three examples-civil activism against tomb-levelling campaign, "the Society of Disciples" (mentuhui), and a ritual service provider. The paper argues that the religioscape of mainland China is one with de facto religious diversity without the ideology of religious pluralism, because the diverse religious practices do not make a conscious reference to pluralism, remain non-institutional, disinterested in religious freedom, and, most important of all, below the state's radar.

Religious Affiliations of the Chinese Community in Australia: Findings from 2016 Census Data

“…As we demonstrated in this report, while broad similarities exist across the Chinese community in Australia, a more nuanced breakdown of the datasets reveals some interesting differences in the religious affiliations of Chinese people who are from different places, speak different dialects, or claim different ancestry. The Greater China Region is a religiously and culturally diverse place despite the efforts that certain regimes in the region have made to overturn or marginalise this trend (Tao 2015;Liang 2018). This diversity is reflected in the data collected through Australia's 2016 Census.…”

Prospects for Covenantal Pluralism in the People's Republic of China: A Reflection on State Policy and Muslim Minorities

“…Despite the flourishing of a wide range of religions and quasi-religions in post-Mao China, religious groups that fall outside the state sanctioned framework have no other channel to gain legitimacy. Thus, although religious variety is evident and religious diversity is "de facto practice" in China, religious pluralism does not exist in China (Liang 2018). In contrast to religious diversity, religious pluralism is a normative concept, an ideology that requires the state to construct an infrastructure to ensure equal treatment of diverse religious groups and equal access to public services (Liang 2018).…”

“…Thus, although religious variety is evident and religious diversity is "de facto practice" in China, religious pluralism does not exist in China (Liang 2018). In contrast to religious diversity, religious pluralism is a normative concept, an ideology that requires the state to construct an infrastructure to ensure equal treatment of diverse religious groups and equal access to public services (Liang 2018). The dominant status of atheist ideology and a fairly strong desire to resuscitate Confucianism as the Chinese civil religion prevent the cultivation of a pluralistic paradigm.…”

“…The dominant status of atheist ideology and a fairly strong desire to resuscitate Confucianism as the Chinese civil religion prevent the cultivation of a pluralistic paradigm. Although the CCP has been pragmatic in formulating its religious policies choosing to co-op selected religions rather than seeking to eliminate all religions at once (Laliberté 2016), religious pluralism is nonetheless "not socially recognized, culturally legitimated, or discursively institutionalized" (Liang 2018).…”