Division, Syllogistic, and Science in Prior Analytics I.31

Abstract

In the first book of the Prior Analytics, Aristotle sets out, for the first time in Greek philosophy, a logical system. After this, Aristotle compares this method with Plato’s method of division, a procedure designed to find essences of natural kinds through systematic classification. This critical comparison in APr I.31 raises an interpretive puzzle: how can Aristotle reasonably juxtapose two methods that differ so much in their aims and approach? What can be gained by doing so? Previous interpreters have failed to show how this comparison is legitimate or what important point Aristotle is making. The goal of this paper is to resolve the puzzle. In resolving this puzzle we not only learn more about the relationship between division and the syllogistic in Aristotle. We will also learn something about the motivation for the syllogistic itself, by seeing the role that it plays in his philosophy of science.

The Discovery of Principles in Prior Analytics 1.30

“…334.8-10, 338.11-15 Wallies;Philoponus, in APr. 307.35-308.4, 313.6-15 Wallies;Striker 2009, 211;Crubellier 2014, 299;2017, 115;Vlasits 2021, 276. 139 Pacius 1605Crubellier 2017, 108 n. 13;Vlasits 2021, 281.…”