Bacillus subtilis phage SP10 DNA has two oxopyrimidines, thymidine 5'-monophosphate (dTMP) and its hypermodified analog (YdTMP). Published data suggest that both are synthesized by postreplicational modification of 5-hydroxymethyldeoxyuridylate (HOMedUMP) in nascent DNA by the following pathway: HOMedUMP-*PPOMedUMP-*dTMP (85%) or YdTMP (15%); PPOMedUMP is 5-(hydroxymethyl-Opyrophosphoryl)deoxyuridylate, the pyrophosphoric acid ester of the C5CH2OH function of HOMedUMP. This paper describes aberrant DNAs synthesized at nonpermissive temperatures by a complementary series of heat-sensitive, modification-defective (mod) mutants. Collectively, these mutants encompass the major steps in the complete modification of nascent SP10 DNA. DNA produced by modA phage retains HOMedUMP as its sole oxopyrimidine, implying that (i) this mutant is defective in the pyrophosphorylation step and (ii) formation of PPOMedUMP is required for any further modification. Furthermore, studies with double mutants indicated that modA is epistatic for all other mod mutants, which supports the hypothesis that modA controls the earliest step in the modification pathway. Since their DNAs contain no YdTMP, modC and modD are defective in hypermodification (i.e., PPOMedUMP-YdTMP). However, dTMP occupies the entire oxopyrimidine fraction of modC DNA, whereas modD DNA has a normal dTMP content, but the now-missing YdTMP is replaced by either PPOMedUMP or a byproduct of abortive hypermodification. It is proposed that the modD mutants are defective in the catalytic aspects of hypermodification and that modC are defective in some regulatory function that promotes hypermodification at the expense of reductive modification (i.e., PPOMedUMP-*dTMP). Reductive modification is defective in modB phage, as evidenced by the absence of dTMP. In contrast to the others, modB DNA has a complex oxopyrimidine content: HOMedUMP, ca. 30%; PPOMedUMP, ca. 40%; and YdTMP, ca. 30%. The expanded level of YdTMP suggests that at certain sites, reductive modification and hypermodification are competing reactions. Interestingly, the PPOMedUMP content of modB DNA seemingly reflects the maximum degree to which phage DNA can be pyrophosphorylated, since the loss of YdTMP from modBmodC and modBmodD DNAs results in a unilateral increase in HOMedUMP content.