Do Electoral Rules Matter for Female Representation?

Abstract

How do electoral rules affect the representation of women? We collect panel data on the universe of Italian politicians from all levels of government over the period 1987-2013 and obtain a complete picture of the career paths of male and female politicians across the whole arc of their careers in public office. We use our unique dataset to analyse the effects on female political representation of an Italian reform which, in 2005, changed the electoral rule for national elections from (mostly) majoritarian to proportional, but did not affect sub-national level elections. We find that proportional electoral rules favour the election of women. We propose a new channel through which this result is obtained, related to the different nature of political competition in the two electoral systems: under proportional rules, parties place women less frequently in competitive seats. This is consistent with the fact that proportional systems value gender diversity more than majoritarian ones, while majoritarian systems rely on head-tohead electoral races, which are not gender neutral. We also find that electoral rules have weaker effects on female representation in geographical areas where traditional gender roles are dominant.JEL-Codes: H700.

Women in Political Bodies as Policymakers

“…One advantage of our local government context is that we can study the effect of women on policies through their influence on council proceedings in a unified framework. 16 16 Our paper also relates to the literature on reasons for female underrepresentation which finds female candidates to be less successful in voting systems centered around persons rather than parties (Profeta and Woodhouse, 2018) likely due to anti-female voter biases (Baskaran and Hessami, 2018;Le Barbanchon and Sauvagnat, 2021).…”

The Councilwoman’s Tale. Countering Intimate Partner Homicides by Electing Women in Local Councils

“…Another possible explanation resides in the different electoral rules governing mayors and councillors in Italy. According to Italian law, mayors are elected through a majoritarian mechanism which is acknowledged to discourage women as its level of competitiveness collides with women's risk aversion (Hessami & da Fonseca, 2020;Profeta & Woodhouse, 2021). Hence, even with moderate and low level of traditional gender norms, it is possible women are more likely to run for councillors to avoid the personalized winner-takes-all mayoral race.…”

Female leaders and gendered laws: A long-term global perspective

“…Historically, women have been underrepresented in leadership positions, especially in political areas that significantly impact national policy (World Economic Forum, 2018). 2 Many scholars have addressed the reasons women have been less involved in the political arena from various perspectives, including social norms (Fox and Lawless, 2004), discrimination against female politicians (Baskaran and Hessami, 2018), political institutions (Profeta and Woodhouse, 2018) and competition avoidance (Gneezy et al, 2009).…”