Do Experiences With Nature Promote Learning? Converging Evidence of a Cause-and-Effect Relationship

Abstract

Do experiences with nature – from wilderness backpacking to plants in a preschool, to a wetland lesson on frogs—promote learning? Until recently, claims outstripped evidence on this question. But the field has matured, not only substantiating previously unwarranted claims but deepening our understanding of the cause-and-effect relationship between nature and learning. Hundreds of studies now bear on this question, and converging evidence strongly suggests that experiences of nature boost academic learning, personal development, and environmental stewardship. This brief integrative review summarizes recent advances and the current state of our understanding. The research on personal development and environmental stewardship is compelling although not quantitative. Report after report – from independent observers as well as participants themselves – indicate shifts in perseverance, problem solving, critical thinking, leadership, teamwork, and resilience. Similarly, over fifty studies point to nature playing a key role in the development of pro-environmental behavior, particularly by fostering an emotional connection to nature. In academic contexts, nature-based instruction outperforms traditional instruction. The evidence here is particularly strong, including experimental evidence; evidence across a wide range of samples and instructional approaches; outcomes such as standardized test scores and graduation rates; and evidence for specific explanatory mechanisms and active ingredients. Nature may promote learning by improving learners’ attention, levels of stress, self-discipline, interest and enjoyment in learning, and physical activity and fitness. Nature also appears to provide a calmer, quieter, safer context for learning; a warmer, more cooperative context for learning; and a combination of “loose parts” and autonomy that fosters developmentally beneficial forms of play. It is time to take nature seriously as a resource for learning – particularly for students not effectively reached by traditional instruction.

Electronic screen technology use and connection to nature in Canadian adolescents: a mixed methods study

“…By increasingly making choices to stay indoors on their screens, young people are missing out on potential health benefits, such as those associated with coping. The latter include improvements in attention span, self-discipline, coping and healing, and resiliency (Kuo et al 2019;Brooks et al 2018;Piccininni et al 2018;Brussoni et al 2012). Efforts to disconnect from screens, even temporarily, and engage in these many benefits surely form the basis for efficacious public health and clinical interventions.…”

A national research agenda supporting green schoolyard development and equitable access to nature

“…In addition to identifying individual outcomes areas relevant to green schoolyard research and evaluation (Figure 1), the Advisors highlighted two additional needs of attending to a) interdisciplinary research and b) strategic research gaps. Though there is a large and growing body of research around the benefits of green schoolyards (see childrenandnature.org/learn/research; childrenandnature.org/learn/ tools-resources; Kuo, Barnes, & Jordan, 2019), by and large, this research does not examine the complexity of green schoolyards or associated programing. Likely because this work is conducted by researchers with specific interests and/or supported by funders with specific priorities, most of the research instead examines isolated benefits in specific cases.…”

Do or do not. There is no try in restoration ecology

“…This is something of a quiet revolution that will not be televised but likely discussed at every restoration and conservation meeting worldwide. People need nature for health and well‐being directly (Berman et al ; Louv ; McMahan & Estes ; Kuo et al ), for landscape‐level maintenance of simple cumulative effects of relatively more natural processes (Diefenderfer et al ), and for the cultural benefits that we derive from a sense of place and access to open areas (Tew et al ). Nonetheless, we live in a time when nature needs us (Dalby ), and our work will never be done.…”