Do the uncertainty relations really have crucial significances for physics ?

Abstract

It is proved the falsity of idea that the Uncertainty Relations (UR) have crucial significances for physics. Additionally one argues for the necesity of an UR-disconnected quantum philosophy.

Annotations regarding the Oxford Questions

“…Here, inspired by the ideas promoted in papers [9,16], we try to present a survey on the mentioned kind. The story of UR subject started from the wish to adopt an unique and generic interpretation for the Heisenberg's thought-experimental formula respectively for the theoretical relation due to Robertson and Schrodinger.…”

“…The story of UR subject started from the wish to adopt an unique and generic interpretation for the Heisenberg's thought-experimental formula respectively for the theoretical relation due to Robertson and Schrodinger. So it was ratified the so called Conventional Interpretation of UR (CIUR) which, in the main, can be expressed [9,16] through few basic items. But [9,16], the respective items proves themselves to be nothing but wrong sentences.…”

“…So it was ratified the so called Conventional Interpretation of UR (CIUR) which, in the main, can be expressed [9,16] through few basic items. But [9,16], the respective items proves themselves to be nothing but wrong sentences. More precisely : (i) Firstly, the Heisenberg's thought-experimental formulas remain as provisional fictions destitute of durable physical significance, (ii) Secondly, the Robertson -Schrodinger relations are simple mathematical interconnection regarding QM fluctuations, from the same family with the formulas concerning fluctuations of MRV and (iii) Thirdly the existence [8][9][10][11]of a quantum-classical probabilistic similarity thanks to which [8,9] the Planck constant h has an authentic classical analog represented by the Boltzmann constant k B , both h and k B being similar generic indicators of stochasticity (randomness).…”

“…We appreciate that, for the studies (debates and researches) which will germinate and grow due to OQ, can be of some nontrivial interest the ideas outlined in above annotations and prefigured in our papers [7][8][9][10][11][12][13][14]16] (certain of them being freely accessible from the mentioned sites). So our hope is that such previsioned studies will be evaluated the real value and utility of the mentioned ideas.…”