Do U.S. Environmental Protection Agency water quality guidelines for recreational waters prevent gastrointestinal illness? A systematic review and meta-analysis.

Abstract

Since the 1950s, numerous studies have examined the association between recreational water quality and health outcomes. Many of these studies have reported an increased risk of illness associated with exposure to recreational water. Several have related the level of contamination in the water, as measured by indicators of water quality, with the magnitude of risk. Despite extensive research on this topic, uncertainty remains about how water quality indicators can best be used in the regulation of recreational water environments. In 1986, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA 1986) published recommended water quality criteria for recreational waters, which proposed the use of enterococci in marine water and enterococci and/or Escherichia coli in fresh water as indicator organisms. That report recommended regulatory levels based on geometric means of at least five samples over a 30-day period of 35 colony-forming units (cfu)/100 mL and 33 cfu/100 mL for enterococci in marine and fresh water, respectively; and 126 cfu/100 mL for E. coli in fresh water (U.S. EPA 1986). Fecal coliforms, which had been previously proposed for use as an indicator, were no longer recommended. The studies upon which these revised guidelines were based (Cabelli 1983;Dufour 1984a) have been criticized (Fleisher 1992), and the draft revised World Health Organization (2001) guidelines have been developed using more recent controlled studies ).Few attempts have been made to summarize and evaluate the existing literature in a systematic and quantitative framework. Pruss (1998) concluded that the literature strongly suggests a dose-response relationship between fecal contamination and the risk of gastrointestinal (GI) illness but did not examine the relationship between specific water quality indicators and health outcomes.Our primary goal in this systematic review was to evaluate the evidence linking specific microbial indicators of recreational water quality to specific health outcomes under nonoutbreak conditions. Secondary goals were to identify and describe critical study design issues, to quantify and evaluate sources of heterogeneity among the studies, and to evaluate the potential for health effects at or below the current suggested regulatory standards. MethodsLiterature search. Our literature search included several computerized databases: MEDLINE (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/ entrez/query.fcgi?db=PubMed), BIOSIS (www.biosis.org), OLDMEDLINE (http:// gateway.nlm.nih.gov/gw/Cmd), and EMBASE (http://openaccess.dialog.com/med/) for the period from 1950 to the present. We searched dissertations using the UMI/ProQuest Digital Dissertation Database (http://wwwlib.umi.com/ dissertations/gateway). The search terms included key words "recreational water and health" and subject heading searches for "environmental pollutants, adverse effects" or "water pollution, adverse effects." We consulted experts in the field and reviewed the bibliographies of relevant studies for additional references. We reviewed the titles and abstracts of a...

Enterococci Concentrations in Diverse Coastal Environments Exhibit Extreme Variability

“…Enterococci (ENT) are the focus of this study because they correlate best to human health outcomes in marine waters (5) (Table 1). During each experiment, samples were taken at a fixed location, and thus sampling was Eulerian in nature.…”

Acute Gastroenteritis and Recreational Water: Highest Burden Among Young US Children

“…Recent waterbody closures at Brazilian Olympic venues 4 and Waikiki beach, Hawaii 5 illustrate recreational water contamination's public health and economic reach. Several cohort studies and randomized trials have measured swimming-related health risks and risks associated with exposure to waters containing elevated fecal indicator bacteria levels, [6][7][8][9][10][11][12][13][14][15][16][17] but individual studies are usually too small to estimate the public health burden associated with water exposure with respect to missed daily activities (work, school, vacation) or medical visits and hospitalizations that result from gastroenteritis. Moreover, individual studies have not typically enrolled enough swimmers to estimate risks separately for children.…”

Regional Public Health Cost Estimates of Contaminated Coastal Waters: A Case Study of Gastroenteritis at Southern California Beaches

“…Dose-Response. Of all the illnesses considered in the literature, GI is most commonly associated with exposure to polluted water (10)(11)(12)(21)(22)(23)(24)(25)(26). To estimate the risk of GI from swimming in contaminated marine waters in southern CA, we utilized two dose-response models (11,12) (Table 1) developed in epidemiology studies conducted elsewhere (in marine waters of the East U.S. coast and United Kingdom) (18,27).…”