Do women’s perspectives of quality of care during childbirth match with those of providers? A qualitative study in Uttar Pradesh, India

Abstract

Background: Persistently high maternal mortality levels are a concern in developing countries. In India, monetary incentive schemes have increased institutional delivery rates appreciably, but have not been equally successful in reducing maternal mortality. Maternal outcomes are affected by quality of obstetric care and socio-cultural norms. In this light there is need to examine the quality of care provided to women delivering in institutions. Objective: This study aimed to examine pregnant women’s expectations of high-quality care in public health facilities in Uttar Pradesh, India, and to contrast this with provider’s perceptions of the same, as well as the barriers that limit their ability to provide high-quality care. Methods: A qualitative descriptive analysis was conducted on data from two studies – focus group discussions with rural women in their last trimester of pregnancy (conducted in 2014) to understand women’s experience and satisfaction with maternal care services, and in-depth interviews with care providers (conducted in 2016–17) to understand provision of person-centred care. Provider perspectives were matched with themes of women’s perspectives on quality of childbirth care in facilities. Results: Major themes of care prioritised by women included availability of doctors at the facility; availability of medicines; food; ambulance services; maintenance of cleanliness and hygiene; privacy; good and safe delivery with no complications; client-provider interaction; financial cost of care. Many women also voiced no expectation of care, indicating disillusionment from the existing system. Providers concurred with women on all themes of care except availability of doctors, as they felt that trained nurses were proficient in conducting deliveries. Conclusions: This study shows that women have clear expectations of quality care from facilities where they go to deliver. Understanding their expectations and matching them with providers’ perspectives of care is critical for efforts to improve the quality of care and thereby impact maternal outcomes.

“I wouldn’t have hit you, but you would have killed your baby:” exploring midwives’ perspectives on disrespect and abusive Care in Ghana

“…The study also revealed that midwives attributed their professional misconduct during intrapartum care to the unwillingness of childbearing women to yield to their instructions. This victim blaming attitude of the midwives have been reported in another study conducted in India in which midwives blamed some of their disrespectful and abusive care practices on non-cooperative attitudes of women who visited the hospital for care [29].…”

“…From a meta-ethnographic study, it is evident that midwives in the United Kingdom (UK) were aware of childbearing women's rights to autonomy but were often faced with a dilemma when childbearing women make birth position choice outside recommended guidelines [23]. Additional cited reasons for the compromise of quality and respectful intrapartum care as reported by Indian providers were noncooperative attitudes of childbearing women and their family as well as structural layout of labour units which does not ensure privacy in labour [29].…”

Quality of antenatal care experience in rural Bangladesh: social support, respect, dignity, communication and counselling

“…While it is possible that visual and auditory privacy was maintained during these visits such as conceptualized in global normative documents (2,46,47), it is also possible that women in Bangladesh conceptualize privacy differently and that their expectations of privacy are maintained even if others, particularly women, can see and hear them during the visit. Alternatively, it is possible that due to the prior experience in public health facilities or prior knowledge about the service delivery process in these facilities, women accepted those aspects challenging their privacy during ANC consultations (48). Women's understandings, expectations and preferences around privacy should be explored to design actions to promote privacy which articulates with their conceptualizations and desires.…”

Determinants of utilization of maternal health care services among mothers in Harare, Zimbabwe

“…This study sought to establish the determinants of utilization of 5 maternal health care services among maternity clients in the HWSWD. Improving utilization of ANC services, institutional delivery services as well as PNC services is an integral approach to achieving greater reductions in maternal and neonatal morbidity and mortality as well as reduction of costs of associated complications to the health sector [14]. Figure 2.…”