Documentation and analysis of traumatic injuries in clinical forensic medicine involving structured light three-dimensional surface scanning versus photography

Abstract

Non-contact three-dimensional (3D) surface scanning has been applied in forensic medicine and has been shown to mitigate shortcoming of traditional documentation methods. The aim of this paper is to assess the efficiency of structured light 3D surface scanning in recording traumatic injuries of live cases in clinical forensic medicine. The work was conducted in Medico-Legal Centre in Benghazi, Libya. A structured light 3D surface scanner and ordinary digital camera with close-up lens were used to record the injuries and to have 3D and two-dimensional (2D) documents of the same traumas. Two different types of comparison were performed. Firstly, the 3D wound documents were compared to 2D documents based on subjective visual assessment. Additionally, 3D wound measurements were compared to conventional measurements and this was done to determine whether there was a statistical significant difference between them. For this, Friedman test was used. The study established that the 3D wound documents had extra features over the 2D documents. Moreover; the 3D scanning method was able to overcome the main deficiencies of the digital photography. No statistically significant difference was found between the 3D and conventional wound measurements. The Spearman's correlation established strong, positive correlation between the 3D and conventional measurement methods. Although, the 3D surface scanning of the injuries of the live subjects faced some difficulties, the 3D results were appreciated, the validity of 3D measurements based on the structured light 3D scanning was established. Further work will be achieved in forensic pathology to scan open injuries with depth information.

The effect of different imaging techniques for the visualisation of evidence in court on jury comprehension

“…Three-dimensional imaging, virtual environments, and simulations are now becoming commonplace in the reconstruction and documentation of crime scenes, artefacts, and skeletal evidence [9][10][11][12][13][14][15][16]. Ampanozi et al [17] demonstrated that the use of 3D reconstructions and colour-coded CT images were a preferred visual format for district attorneys for understanding radiological findings.…”

Determining the Effectiveness of Noncontact Three‐Dimensional Surface Scanning for the Assessment of Open Injuries

“…In this research, the mannequins were physically manipulated while the scanner (camera and projector) was tilted and rotated to expose these areas to the light for the optimal working of the camera. The areas were scanned, and the angulation of the scanner during the 3D scanning had no impact on the 3D results . Figure shows the 3D result of the undermined area of the stage‐4 pressure injury (mannequin B).…”

“…The Pico scan portable structured light 3D scanner has been applied to reconstruct various traumatic injuries from living victims , and the Artec Eva hand‐held structured light 3D scanner has been used to scan injury tattoos on a volunteer subject . It has been shown that these 3D methods are more useful and address the main shortcomings of digital photography that relate to lighting conditions, angle of acquisition and distance . Additionally, linear 3D wound measurements based on these techniques have been validated in both studies.…”

The impact of personal perception on the identification of tattoo pattern in human identification

“…Recent work (Shamata and Thompson, 2018) has shown that the use of 3D surface scanning can support the work of forensic medical practitioners, partly by allowing for surface detail to be recorded with topographic anatomical detail. This approach was attempted here using a FARO Gage Plus.…”