Does chaos theory have major implications for philosophy of medicine?

Abstract

In the literature it is sometimes claimed that chaos theory, non-linear dynamics, and the theory of fractals have major implications for philosophy of medicine, especially for our analysis of the concept of disease and the concept of causation. This paper gives a brief introduction to the concepts underlying chaos theory and non-linear dynamics. It is then shown that chaos theory has only very minimal implications for the analysis of the concept of disease and the concept of causation, mainly because the mathematics of chaotic processes entail that these processes are fully deterministic. The practical unpredictability of chaotic processes, caused by their extreme sensitivity to initial conditions, may raise practical problems in diagnosis, prognosis, and treatment, but it raises no major theoretical problems. The relation between chaos theory and the problem of free will is discussed, and it is shown that chaos theory may remove the problem of predictability of decisions, but does not solve the problem of free will. Chaos theory may thus be very important for our understanding of physiological processes, and specific disease entities, without having any major implications for philosophy of medicine.

A silly expression: Consultants’ implicit and explicit understanding of Medical Humanities. A qualitative analysis

“…Literature in the Medical Humanities deals extensively with these issues, critically discussing the relevant merits of different approaches, for example, the usefulness of Chaos theory and how to better prepare medical students for later practice. 17 Approaches to medical care (Theme 3, examples in Box 5), included understanding the role of the doctor, and of medicine in society, were commonly discussed by clinicians. This has long been considered within the history of medicine; 18 6).…”

Multiple organ dysfunction syndrome pathogenesis and care: a complex systems’ theory perspective

“…First, complex systems’ theory by illustrating the immense complexity of living systems that act as wholes evolving through unpredictability has unexpectedly corroborated the theoretical assumptions of holism. Second, a major implication appears to be the shift in the conceptualization of disease as an evolving variable state (Holm, 2002) rather than as a mere breakdown.…”

Complexity modeling: Identify instability early

“…This may be the reason why subjects with depression have an increased risk of cancer and infection and why a positive attitude is an important component of the arsenal for recovery. For a detailed discussion of this topic and specific references, the reader is referred to recent review articles (16,17).…”