Does data visualization affect users’ understanding of electricity consumption?

Abstract

Different data visualizations are investigated for how they enable occupants to learn about domestic energy consumption. Smart metering can potentially encourage householders to change their behaviour and save energy. However, concerns exist about whether users understand domestic energy feedback. Two challenges are addressed: feedback displays typically show aggregate consumption and they show time-series data visualizations, which are difficult to relate to everyday actions in the household. A laboratory experiment (N = 43) assessed changes in participants' knowledge of how much electricity everyday actions consume after being exposed to different forms of energy-consumption data visualizations: (1) an aggregated time-series line graph, (2) a disaggregated time-series line graph and (3) a normalized disaggregated visualization that deemphasized time. Participants played an energy game both before and after they saw the simulation. Participants in condition (3) were more accurate and more confident in their post-test judgments about everyday domestic electricity consumption than other participants. These findings suggest that the type of data visualization affects users' understanding of domestic electricity consumption. The visualization of disaggregated energy feedback at the appliance level should be considered for future generations of technology.

From discovering to delivering: A critical reflection on eco-feedback, application design, and participatory research in the United Kingdom

“…However, disaggregated energy feedback can be more impactful when participants are already motivated ("energy enthusiastic"). The findings of other scholars [41]; on the other hand, were in disagreement as they advised that energy savings made with disaggregated Eco-feedback systems were superior to when utilising the aggregated ones.…”

A Case Study of Socially-Accepted Potentials for the Use of End User Flexibility by Home Energy Management Systems

“…In combination with PV systems, these recommendations subsequently increase both the self-consumption and the self-sufficiency. Ideally, HEMSs enable users to avoid energy waste and monitor energy consumption, which is subject to the condition that end users comprehend its content [24]. HEMSs either analyze the entire building, individual rooms, or single appliances [23].…”

Integration of Building Information Modelling and Augmented Reality for Building Energy Systems Visualisation

“…In order to meet sustainability goals and mitigate climate change, energy systems must be more effective [2]. The visualisation of energy systems' performance can enhance the user's understanding of the system and, therefore, their decision-making relating to them [3]. Buildings consist of several energy systems, such as the heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) systems, lighting systems and electric motors, out of which heating, space cooling, water heating, and lighting accounted for nearly 70% of site energy consumption [4].…”