Does equality legislation reduce intergroup differences? Religious affiliation, socio-economic status and mortality in Scotland and Northern Ireland: A cohort study of 400,000 people

Abstract

Religion frequently indicates membership of socio-ethnic groups with distinct health behaviours and mortality risk. Determining the extent to which interactions between groups contribute to variation in mortality is often challenging. We compared socio-economic status (SES) and mortality rates of Protestants and Catholics in Scotland and Northern Ireland, regions in which interactions between groups are profoundly different. Crucially, strong equality legislation has been in place for much longer and Catholics form a larger minority in Northern Ireland. Drawing linked Census returns and mortality records of 404,703 people from the Scottish and Northern Ireland Longitudinal Studies, we used Poisson regression to compare religious groups, estimating mortality rates and incidence rate ratios. We fitted age-adjusted and fully adjusted (for education, housing tenure, car access and social class) models. Catholics had lower SES than Protestants in both countries; the differential was larger in Scotland for education, housing tenure and car access but not social class. In Scotland, Catholics had increased age-adjusted mortality risk relative to Protestants but variation among groups was attenuated following adjustment for SES. Those reporting no religious affiliation were at similar mortality risk to Protestants. In Northern Ireland, there was no mortality differential between Catholics and Protestants either before or after adjustment. Men reporting no religious affiliation were at increased mortality risk but this differential was not evident among women. In Scotland, Catholics remained at greater socio-economic disadvantage relative to Protestants than in Northern Ireland and were also at a mortality disadvantage. This may be due to a lack of explicit equality legislation that has decreased inequality by religion in Northern Ireland during recent decades.

Administrative Data Research Northern Ireland (ADR NI)

“…Statistical techniques such as eDataShield [15] will provide a workable interim solution. This technique facilitates combined analysis of physically separated datasets, including datasets such as the Census where strict security access usually prevents these data being pooled [16,17]. However, there is obviously a potential need to move towards scenarios where the individual-level data across the UK are combined and analysed in one setting.…”

Research on the evaluation and configuration path of China's rural common Prosperity—NCA and fsQCA based on provincial panel data

“…Since the connotation of CP requires both material and spiritual satisfaction, these two methods are highly recognized. Some scholars have also used methods such as the Theil Index [ 23 ] and the Lorenz curve [ 24 ] to measure rural CP. However, due to the volatility of indicator measurement and the singularity of dimensions, there may be significant deviations in the measurement results.…”

Trust, forgiveness, and peace: The influence of adolescent social identity in a setting of intergroup conflict

“…However, group-based differences in status and power remain. For example, Catholics often have lower socio-economic status in comparison with Protestants, and political parties representing the Catholic community are the minority faction within the power sharing government (Wright et al, 2017). The post-accord society continues to be divided along traditional group lines; day-to-day events are still viewed and understood within the context of group membership (Muldoon et al, 2007), even among children (Taylor et al, 2020a).…”