“…There is an ongoing debate on EKC, and scholars present different views on the role of income in mitigating pollution due to various pollution reduction patterns across regions and countries. Some studies support the existence of EKC (Baloch, Mahmood, & Zhang, 2019; Dong, Sun, & Hochman, 2017; Halkos & Polemis, 2017; Jebli, Youssef, & Ozturk, 2016), whereas others do not confirm EKC (Ozturk, 2015; Sohag, Kalugina, & Samargandi, 2019; Tedino, 2017). At the initial stage, economic development increases environmental pollution due scale effect because economic growth exploits natural resources, promotes industrialization, and intensifies agriculture (Baloch et al, 2019).…”