Does Mentoring Directly Improve Students’ Research Skills? Examining the Role of Information Literacy and Competency Development

Abstract

This work proposes a structural model highlighting the research skills of undergraduate students. Due to the stages in their research project implementation, mentoring students becomes a crucial initiative in higher education institutions. Despite substantial progress in the literature linking mentoring and skills development, there is a lack of greater emphasis on research skills, especially for undergraduate students facing research work for the first time. Consequently, the direct relation between mentoring and research skills may not be straightforward. Thus, driven by social learning theory, the proposed model highlights the mediating effects of information literacy constructs and competency development on the relationship between mentoring and research skills. An empirical study of 539 participants via Partial Least Squares–Structural Equation Modeling supports six of the seven hypothesized paths. Three major theoretical contributions arise from the findings. Firstly, mentoring improves information-seeking skills and information-sharing behaviors and facilitates students’ competency development due to the technical knowledge transfer from the faculty mentor to student mentees. Secondly, information literacy constructs and competency development promote research skills, emphasizing that students with those behaviors and capacities will achieve enhanced research skills. Finally, our findings suggest that mentoring does not directly translate to improved research skills; instead, information-seeking and sharing behaviors and competency development fully mediate such a link. Thus, mentors must shape these behaviors for mentoring to develop students’ research skills. Theoretical and practical insights are outlined from these findings for university leadership to inform the design of mentoring initiatives for undergraduate students.

Exploring student perceptions: Factors influencing academic performance in a school of pharmacy in Nigeria

“…It highlights the importance of effective mentorship and guidance in helping students navigate the complexities of their academic journey (Jegede et al, 2023). This finding aligns with studies emphasising the pivotal role of mentorship in promoting student success and satisfaction (Cutillas et al, 2023;Saranya et al, 2023).…”

A model to reconstruct lecturer dilemma in balancing research and teaching responsibilities: A case of one rural university in South Africa

“…This not only hampers the research output of academics but also limits their ability to stay up-to-date with the latest research findings. The participants' desire to guide students in research projects, but facing challenges due to time constraints and lack of research support, resonates with the findings of Cutillas et al (2023), who emphasise the importance of mentorship and support for students' research endeavours. Overall, the participants' views underscore the critical need for institutional support and funding to enhance research capacity and facilitate meaningful engagement with the community.…”

Harnessing Information Technology in Learning: Exploring Emerging Trends and Innovative Approaches

“…By decoupling learning from traditional academic structures and timelines, CBE enables learners to accelerate their progress, remediate areas of weakness, and pursue personalized learning goals. Additionally, CBE fosters a culture of continuous improvement and lifelong learning by emphasizing the acquisition of transferable skills, competencies, and dispositions that are relevant in diverse personal, academic, and professional contexts (Cutillas et al, 2023).…”