Does monitor position influence visual-motor performance during minimally invasive surgery?

Abstract

Background: In minimally invasive surgery (MIS), the natural relationship between hand and eye is disrupted, i.e. surgeons typically control tools inserted through the patient's abdomen while viewing the workspace on a remote monitor, which can be located in a variety of positions. This separates the location of visual feedback from the area in which a motor action is executed. Previous studies suggest that the visual display should be placed directly ahead of the surgeon (i.e. to preserve visual-motor mapping). However, the extent of the impact of this rotation on surgical performance is unknown. Methods: Eighteen participants completed an aiming task on a tablet PC within a surgical box trainer using a laparoscopic tool in a controlled simulated environment. Visual feedback was presented on a remote monitor located at 0 , AE 45and AE 90 , with order randomised using the Latin Square method. Results: Movements were significantly slower when the monitor was 90 relative to midline, but spatial accuracy was unaffected by monitor position. Interestingly, the effect of reduced speed in the 90 condition was transient, decreasing over time, suggesting rapid adaptation to the rotation. Conclusions: We conclude that the angle of the visual display in the context of MIS may require a surgeon to adapt to a changed mapping between visual inputs and motor outputs. While this adaptation occurs relatively quickly, it may interfere with skilled actions (e.g. intracorporeal suturing) in complex surgical procedures.

Feedback and motor skill acquisition using a haptic dental simulator

“…Demonstrable success in improving standards has come from the aviation industry – where flight simulators have contributed to drastic improvements in safety – and the military . In health care, and specifically surgery, computer simulation has become increasingly prevalent as a means of training clinicians, evaluating competency and as a tool for reducing errors . Dentistry is relatively unique amongst healthcare specialities in that it has a long history of using simulators in training .…”

Towards virtual displays in the interventional radiology suite: a feasibility study

“…al, in which they performed a previous study aiming to quantify the effects of the VMFD problem in image-guided surgery. 1 We plan to expand our system to display both US and Fluoroscopy and create a customizable workflow for endoleak repair, a procedure which typically requires both US and Fluoroscopy for guidance. Using either hand gestures or voice commands, the clinician will be able to swap seamlessly between modalities and position the displays in their desired location, without worry about interference from the C-Arm, ceiling-mounted monitor, or US machine.…”

“…Often, due to lack of space, the clinician have to perform a procedure with the display in a sub-optimal position, increasing the visual motor field disparity (VMFD) already inherently present in imageguided procedures. 1 Without adequate visualization of the imaging displays, procedure time and radiation dose increase, targeting accuracy decreases, and the overall ability to perform a safe and successful procedure is jeopardized.…”

Totally Endoscopic Uniportal Surgical Aortic Valve Replacement via Transcervical Approach: How to Do It

“…Studies of endoscopic skill learning have consistently shown that the visual display should be placed directly ahead of the operator to preserve visual-motor mapping. 16 The monitor is sheathed in a sterile drape with clear window after the screen protective cover has been peeled off.…”