Does Perfectionism Predict Depression, Anxiety, Stress, and Life Satisfaction After Controlling for Neuroticism?

Abstract

Abstract. Neuroticism overlaps substantially with several perfectionism dimensions, depression, anxiety, stress, and life satisfaction. Accordingly, research testing whether perfectionism dimensions explain unique variance in these outcomes beyond neuroticism is needed. Research on cultural differences in perfectionism is also scarce. And it is especially unclear whether the link between perfectionism and psychological distress differs across individualistic and collectivistic cultures. Our study addressed these important gaps in knowledge. A sample of undergraduates from a traditionally individualistic culture (Canada; N = 449) and a traditionally collectivistic culture (China; N = 585) completed measures of self-oriented perfectionism, personal standards, socially prescribed perfectionism, concern over mistakes, doubts about actions, depression, anxiety, stress, and satisfaction with life. To test the incremental validity of perfectionism dimensions beyond neuroticism, as well as to test potential moderating effects of culture, four hierarchical regression analyses with interactions were conducted. Results supported the explanatory power of concern over mistakes and doubts about actions, beyond neuroticism and culture, in the prediction of depression, anxiety, and stress. As the first study to explore the incremental validity of perfectionism dimensions across undergraduates from traditionally individualistic and collectivistic cultures, our research both extends and clarifies understanding of the predictive power of perfectionism in important ways.

Perfectionism and depressive symptoms: The effects of psychological detachment from work

“…The different sources of pressure were not separately investigated in the current study. Furthermore, recent evidence suggests that both the level and consequences of socially prescribed perfectionism are tied to the extent to which the individual's social environment involves exposure to criticism and demands to be perfect (Smith, Speth, et al, 2017;Smith, Saklofske, Yan, & Sherry, 2017).…”

Factor structure and psychometric properties of a Polish adaptation of the Frost Multidimensional Perfectionism Scale

“…In studies on perfectionism the status of the ORG scale is unclear. Therefore, some researchers using FMPS decide to sum up the scores of the ORG and PS scales creating an indicator of perfectionistic strivings (Shih 2012) while others decide to include only PS and to avoid ORG (Smith et al 2017). This can make it difficult to compare different studies, even those conducted on the same population.…”

A clinical interpretation of shame regulation in maladaptive perfectionism

“…Diagnostically, perfectionism is associated with OCD (Egan et al, 2011;Glickauf-Hughes and Wells, 1995), narcissism (Mann, 2004) and depression (Ashby et al, 2006;Jahromi et al, 2012;Malinowski, Veselka & Atkinson, 2017;Smith, Saklofske, Yan & Sherry, 2017).…”