Does public consultation encourage social participation?

Abstract

Purpose Social participation or public participation is a mechanism that aims to enable decision makers to understand the real needs of society and to promote more appropriate and acceptable public policies. The purpose of this paper is to analyze, through Douglasian Cultural Theory, the public-consultation mechanism, and to what extent it encourages the participation of people with different points of view in the formulation of public policies. Design/methodology/approach This research paper uses theoretical propositions from Douglasian Cultural Theory to investigate the process of public consultation adopted by the Brazilian National Health Surveillance Agency (Anvisa) in the formulation of public policies for Brazil’s health sector. Findings The results contribute to the findings of previous studies, i.e., that social participation is unequal, and that some points of view are dominant in policy formulation. This indicates that public managers should seek mechanisms of participation that promote more inclusive and pluralistic public participation. Research limitations/implications The main limitations of this study are the subjectivity inherent in the classification of “voices” in Douglasian Cultural Theory, the small number of contributions analyzed and the absence of some unpublished data. Originality/value The analysis contributes to the literature by supporting some and rejecting other propositions of Douglasian Cultural Theory, as well as indicating possible potential from this theory through public administration in the evaluation of mechanisms of social participation.

Adoption of Information Technology in Public Administration: a Focus on the Organizational Factors of a Brazilian Federal University

“…The management trend that guides innovation in Public Administration is the expansion of the use of information technology as a means of promoting the efficiency of public services (Bertot et al, 2012;Borins, 2001;Saab et al, 2019). In this way, its use allows new forms of social participation in the management of resources, giving greater legitimacy to public policies for the benefit of effectiveness, responsiveness, transparency, and governance (Edimara Mezzomo Luciano et al, 2018;Saab et al, 2018). In this context, IT becomes one of the main drivers of innovation in the public sector, offering new services such as issuing online certificates, consulting information of an individual or collective interest, monitoring of online processes, "digital" service stations, among others (Koch & Hauknes, 2005;Von Haldenwang, 2004).…”

Public consultation in the construction of the District Food and Nutrition Policy

“…It gives people a powerful voice in political choices and aims to engage civil society in collective decisions. Participation facilitates a better understanding of which public problems should be prioritized from people's perspective 22 .…”

Evaluation of Public Consultation in an Environmental Impact Assessment Procedure. A Case Study

“…Commitment to public issues often takes the form of public consultation. The process is aimed at optimising future decisions by giving the participants the opportunity to voice their demands and proposed solutions (Saab 2018). Gawrońska, G., Gawroński, K., Król, K., Jarosz, K. (2020).…”