Does Simulation Training for Acute Care Nurses Improve Patient Safety Outcomes: A Systematic Review to Inform Evidence‐Based Practice

Abstract

Background: Simulation is increasingly used as a training tool for acute care medical-surgical nurses to improve patient safety outcomes. A synthesis of the evidence is needed to describe the characteristics of research studies about acute care nurse simulation trainings and patient safety. An additional purpose is to examine the effects of acute care registered nurse (RN) simulation trainings on patient safety outcomes.Methods: Five Internet databases were searched for articles published on any date through October 2018 examining the effect of RN simulation trainings on patient safety outcomes in the adult acute care setting.Sample: N = 12 articles represented 844 RNs of varying experience levels and 271 interprofessional participants.Results: Nine studies (75%) used high-fidelity scenarios developed locally about high risk but infrequent events. Five studies (42%) incorporated interdisciplinary team members in the scenarios and/or outcome evaluations. Outcome measures were self-reported, direct observation, or clinical indicators. All studies in this review achieved improved patient safety outcomes. It is unknown how outcomes vary for different groups of RNs because of insufficient gender, ethnicity/race, and age reporting.Linking Evidence to Action: Findings support the design of simulation training research studies for patient safety outcomes and use of simulation training and research in acute care RNs. Additional high-quality research is needed to support this field. Future studies should include descriptors that characterize the sample (i.e., age, gender, education level, type of nursing degree, ethnicity or race, or years of experience); incorporate interdisciplinary teams; evaluate a combination of outcome measure types (i.e., self-report, direct observation, and clinical outcomes) both proximal and distal to the simulation; and that utilize standardized scenarios, validated outcome measure instruments, and standardized debriefing tools.Additional supporting information may be found in the online version of this article at the publisher's web site: Figure S1. A proposed model of simulation based training for patient safety outcomes in acute care nursing. Table S1. Characteristics of studies evaluating simulation based training for RNs and patient safety outcomes.

Toward an Integrative Nursing Curriculum: Combining Team-Based and Problem-Based Learning with Emergency-Care Scenario Simulation

“…To prevent such medical errors in a clinical setting, the most effective strategy is to incorporate situational, scenario-driven training exercises into nursing education and professional training. These exercises can help students acquire basic and advanced nursing knowledge and skills [21]. Scenario-simulation teaching has proven effective in medical and nursing education.…”

The Impact of Simulation on Graduate Entry Master's Students' Confidence to Provide Safe Patient Care: A Longitudinal Study

“…For health professional education, the impact of SBE on learner outcomes and how this translates into subsequent practice are particular areas of current investigation (Seaton et al, 2019). However, the focus of research tends to be on practicing clinicians and high performing teams (Lewis et al, 2019) rather than students and safe patient care.…”

Student perception of early simulation in dentistry

“…27 Regarding the evaluation of the simulation in general, students have given a high score to good teaching practices, this may be due to the correct implementation of the practical sessions in relation to the active participation of the teachers, proper use of theoretical and practical materials, and the correct sequence of the session. 1,9,28, 29 No association was found in the perception of skill, scenarios, and simulation practices in general with the variables age, gender, level, and previous experience. Regarding age, a study, carried out by Fernández et al, 14 in Barcelona stated that the perception regarding simulation does not show differences according to age, a result that coincides with the present study.…”