Does the Adaptive Market Hypothesis Reconcile the Behavioral Finance and the Efficient Market Hypothesis?

Abstract

This study aims to test the adaptive market hypothesis by using the myopic behavior of investors as a new proxy. The data have been taken from New York Stock Exchange from December 1994 to December 2020. Following this collection of data, the companies’ stock prices were distributed into six different portfolios based on size, investment, a book-to-market value, and operating profit. Ordinal logistic regression was used to calculate the probability of recovery of losses after experiencing a decline in the market. As part of the robustness analysis, this study replaces the Sharpe ratio with a Lower Partial Moment ratio. Most of the results for the Sharpe ratio and Lower Partial Moment ratio are similar. During 1995–1999, 2002–2006, and 2010–2020, the investors have not shown myopic behavior towards losses, but from 2000–2001 and 2007–2009 the investors exhibited myopic characteristics. Furthermore, as investors move between myopic and non-myopic loss aversion, the study reports that the US market is both efficient and inefficient at various points in time, following the adaptive market hypothesis. Thus, such a finding could act as a basis for future investment models by adapting traditional models or by building and contributing to the development of new ones.

Limitations and Critique of Modern Portfolio Theory: A Comprehensive Literature Review

“…Additionally, Soni, K., & Desai, M. conducted grouped surveys based on different age and gender categories and found that variations in risk tolerance among different age groups can impact investors' decision-making [4]. Consequently, the rise of behavioral finance, which incorporates emotional factors and investors' irrational behavior, has led to the development of behavioral portfolio theory (BPT) as a more comprehensive investment strategy [5][6][7]. It is suggested for application in real markets.…”

“…Such unforeseen events can affect investors' purchasing power and the stock prices of various industries, deviating from predictions based on historical data and contradicting theoretical assumptions. Therefore, in Noreen et al's article, they proposed the Adaptive Market Hypothesis, suggesting that markets may not swiftly adjust to restore equilibrium in certain situations [7]. Investors may remain rational under normal circumstances but become irrational during exceptional periods.…”

Enhancing Analytical Precision in Company Earnings Reports through Neurofuzzy System Development: A Comprehensive Investigation

“…Te stock price can be afected by news, events, and information about the release of new products. Information determines the movement of fnancial markets according to the efcient market hypothesis (EMH) [12]. Te EMH model assumes that stock prices are determined by a random walk model.…”