Does the ‘One Map Initiative’ Represent a New Path for Forest Mapping in Indonesia? Assessing the Contribution of the REDD+ Initiative in Effecting Forest Governance Reform

Abstract

This study investigates one notable result that the REDD+ ('Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and forest Degradation, and enhancing forest carbon stocks and conservation') initiative effected within Indonesia's forest institutions. It argues that during its interplay with existing National forest institutions REDD+ produced a significant benefit; namely, the 'one map initiative' (OMI) being the government's response to the call for greater transparency and enabling of REDD+ implementation. It asks: "Does the 'One Map Initiative' signify a switch to a new path of map-making, or is it just another innovation within an existing path dependence of forest governance?" Through eighty semi-structured interviews with 'REDD+ policy actors' and the deployment of 'path dependence' theory, this study seeks to determine the extent to which the REDD+ initiative created a 'critical juncture' (i.e., momentum for institutions to move to a new path). This study maps the institutional path dependence within forest-mapping as a means for the state to gain control of forest resources. In its development process the OMI has shown its ability to break the old path-dependence of map-making (e.g., lack of transparency, low level of public participation, and poor coordination amongst ministries). Moreover, this paper identified several historical events (i.e., 'critical junctures') that preceded the REDD+ initiative as contributing factors to the relative success of REDD+ in effecting forest governance reform.

What influences the implementation of natural climate solutions? A systematic map and review of the evidence

“…Land-use planning-mapping, identification of land-use drivers, and assessment of ecological conditions-came up almost as often as MRV (n = 39). Planning prior to project or program activities can aid implementation, in particular in the long-term (Blomley et al 2017, Mulyani andJepson 2017). Ensuring compatible practices or adoption of integrated approaches were a consideration in 7% of observations (n = 16).…”

Costs and Carbon Sequestration Assessment for REDD+ in Indonesia

“…In Southeast Asia, plantations in Indonesia and Malaysia undoubtedly hold economic importance in the region [68][69][70]. These financial revenues have become more aggressive with the palm oil price boom.…”

India in the Oil Palm Era: Describing India’s Dependence on Palm Oil, Recommendations for Sustainable Production, and Opportunities to Become an Influential Consumer

“…In Malaysia, Jaringan Orang Asal Se-Malaysia', a collective of 21 NGOs focusing on advocacy issues of indigenous communities, and Malaysian Palm Oil NGO Coalition, with various environmental NGOs, play an important role in environmental protection (RSPO, 2013). Government actions, such as the One-Map Initiative (Mulyani & Jepson, 2016), identification of sustainable oil palm producers and traders (Bahuet, 2017;Zoological Society of London, 2017), and the peatland restoration agency of Indonesia (Badan Restorasi Gambut, 2015), have been successful in regulating the oil palm industry better. In the context of the success of NGOs and government initiatives in Indonesia and Malaysia, we advocate similar initiatives in India.…”