Does WTO Accession Help Domestic Reform? The Political Economy of SOE Reform Backsliding in Vietnam

Abstract

Conventional wisdom holds that international trade agreements can serve as a source of external pressure and credible commitment to overcome opposition and to lock in domestic economic reforms. This belief, however, underestimates the ability of politicians not only to circumvent these pressures, but to leverage international trade agreements to advance their own policy preferences – preferences that may be highly anti-reformist. Thus, trade agreements do not necessarily induce reforms and, in certain circumstances, they can even be counterproductive. Through an analysis of aggregate data and 40 interviews with senior politicians, government officials, and state-owned enterprise managers in Vietnam, this paper illustrates these insights by analyzing the political economy of SOE reform backsliding on the eve of Vietnam's accession to the WTO.

The sustainable development of rural-to-urban food supply chains in developing nations

“…Fortunately, Vietnam has successfully transformed from a command to a market economy, allowing individual ownership of businesses since the early 1990s (The World Bank, 2019). It joined the World Trade Organization in 2007 and is recognized as one of 20 economies that contributed most to the world's economic growth according to the International Monetary Fund in 2019 (Vu-Thanh, 2017; Tanzi and Lu, 2019). Meanwhile, according to Lim et al .…”

Tussle for space: The politics of mock‐compliance with global financial standards in developing countries

“…Yet, compliance never followed implementation, in large part because of conflicting interests of the incumbent government. While the Communist Party was steering the economy in a more market friendly direction, it also sought to maintain firm control over the economy, with state‐owned enterprises (SOEs) playing “the decisive role in holding fast the socialist orientation, stability, and economic, political and social development of the country” (Vietnamese Communist Party as cited in Vu‐Thanh 2017). Because banks played a crucial role in providing soft credit to Vietnam's expanding SOEs, financial regulators routinely overlooked banks' lack of compliance.…”

A Resurgent East Asia: Navigating a Changing World

“…The WTO accession did not reduce the role of SOEs but, to the contrary, served as a catalyst for their further entrenchment. Concerned that trade openness would leave the domestic market swamped by foreign competition, the Vietnamese leadership consolidated selected SOEs into large state-owned economic groups (SEGs) in the image of chaebols in the Republic of South Korea a (Baccini, Impullitti, and Malesky 2017;Vu-Thanh 2017). In addition to their scale, these SEGs still enjoy significant advantages over domestic and foreign competitors, including easier access to land, credit, and public procurement contracts.…”